Thee Upper Crust Pizzeria

Grant Wells

2024-05

Thee Upper Crust Pizzeria is THEE number one pizza joint in Pardeeville! The young man who guided us through our pizza journey was very friendly, helpful, and kind!We started with a chilled and carbonated beverage, ordered two 10" pizzas... gyro special and Hot Taco. Both great tasting and loaded with toppings.While we waited God our pizzas, we were provided with markers and crayons to add our own artwork to the paper table cover. Super FUN!Our favorite place for dinner in Pardeeville!

lisa rochwite

2024-04

…More

Jeff P.

2024-04

…More

Becky Howland

2024-02

My husband and I tried this place for the first time on a Thursday evening. Fun atmosphere, clean and kid friendly with arcade games, crayons and coloring pages available. We ordered breaded mozzarella sticks for app and they came out quickly and were hot and done perfectly. Ordered deep dish pizza 14" so to have leftovers. Ohhhh it was DELICIOUS! Lots of melty cheese, fresh & perfectly cooked crust. Very attentive service and owner was so friendly and checked to make sure we were enjoying our experience. We did! We will be back. Excellent experience!

Corey Hendrix

2022-05

I ordered a large Margherita style pizza and got this. Covered in cheese and grease. Overall just a complete mess. Not to mention the price. I only live about a half mile away from the place and they proceeded to charge a 10 dollar delivery fee. Altogether this mess of a pizza was $40 and $40 dollars wasted. I’d be embarrassed to call myself an authentic pizza restaurant putting out stuff like this. Only thing this place has going for them is that they’re convenient and close. I will be going to portage next time I want pizza.

Brenda Lange

2024-04

…More

Courtney Olson

2024-03

…More

Bettina Reinhart

2024-02

Owner is very came out and greeted us we had a little one and he made sure he had plentyof kid friendlyactivities.Staff are very attentive, and the food is phenomenal. THANKS FOR A GREAT EXPERIENCE.Kid-friendliness: The owner brought markers,activity sheets and the table had a piece of paper so we could all enjoy coloring as a family. Your never too old to color!Wheelchair accessibility: There were ramps through the entire building

Alexandra Timpe

2023-07

We put in an order for delivery and the man on the phone was so helpful answered all my questions and double checked that they could deliver to us. You can pay over the phone with your card as well. We were given an estimated time of 1 hour and 15 minutes to 1 and a half hours but assured it would sooner. Our delivery person called me to let us know there was a mix up in the kitchen but she was 10 minutes out. She got to our house and apologized about being late but she wasn’t, it was right in the time frame given. I went to take the pizza from her at the car and she asked if we could do it closer to the house so she could make sure we got everything we ordered. At that point I was like this place is awesome for checking that with us. Everything was there! We ordered the cheesy gravy bread-that was the crowd pleaser everyone loved it!! The garlic breadsticks are homemade and you get so many for the price. They were also delicious! The thin crust pepperoni pizza was amazing. But the most talked about was the deluxe thin crust, it was phenomenal! I highly recommend this place! The service or food alone could keep me coming back but the fact that there’s great service AND food, will keep me coming back.

Marlene Lembcke

2024-03

…More

Mike Ollendorf

2023-07

…More

Robert Gorder

2024-03

…More

Roberta “Bobbie” Flower

2023-11

…More

Marc Roen

2023-05

…More

Danelle Price

2023-05

…More

Harry Stritter

2023-09

…More

Clarissa Bavester

2023-09

…More

Eric Vinz

2023-05

Better than most but not as good as I expected. Nice thick sauce but a bit bland. Cheese on pizza is straight mozzarella. Deep dish crust is just bread dough. None of it's bad and it's definitely better than any chain place but it's close to being so much better.

Kerry R

2023-05

So delicious! We had a party of 5. I had a thin crust with Onion, Pineapple, and Italian Beef. So good. And a delicious crust! Also ordered were the bbq thin crust, 2 deep dish and a pan. We all agree! One of the best places around! And a huge shout out to our waitress! When we arrived, it wasn't very busy. Within 10 minutes it got super busy, and our waitress made sure our drinks stayed filled and she was so nice. Highly recommend!

Marc A

2022-05

Small town, big flavor. This pizza is amazing. If your in the area drop in. The service is good, people are kind, food is delicious. Everything is home made. The food was ready incredibly fast. If we didn't live so far away this would be our new pizza spot!

krystle poulson

2020-05

We live in Portage and this is hands down the best pizza we have had in a 30 mile radius. The breadsticks are to die for

Shayla Duernberger

2022-05

The service I experienced while picking up food was amazing. The staff was extremely friendly and had wonderful attitudes. A man who was working held open the doors for me while carrying out my pizza and breadsticks as well. When I got there my food was fresh out of the oven. It smelled amazing and tasted even better. This place is worth the drive for me and I live an hour and a half away. Will definitely be coming back!!!

Victoria Anderson

2020-05

Stumbled upon this pizza gem with the family and we are excited to have found a great local pizza place! Thin crust and deep dish pizzas were both delicious. Great pricing. The owner and staff were super friendly and kind to us and our child. Definitely will be regulars here!

Phil Kamrath

2023-09

…More

Debra Cochenet

2023-06

…More

Margaret Wichern

2019-05

Casey, the Owner took care of us today. He is very passionate about his work and his business. Tasty food and very generous portions. Small, local business using fresh ingredients and cooking to order. Well worth a visit and well worth the wait for a fresh, hot, filling pizza! I will definitely be visiting here again soon.

Alan Scott

2022-05

The pizza here is fantastic. I grew up in Racine and was spoiled by the Italian community and all the great Italian food. When we moved up northwe couldn't find anything that we were use to. We would periodically drive back to Racine for pizza. Then we found the Upper Crust. No more trips needed.

Maddie Heise

2022-05

Pizza was amazing! We had the thin crust and it was great. Came out quickly as well which was a plus since we have impatient kids 😂 Our waitress was super friendly, helpful and attentive. We'll definitely be back when we're in the area 👍

Justin Marthaler

2022-05

Good place to take a large group. There's a nice large area in the back. Good food and friendly service. We had the chicken Alfredo pizza and it was fantastic. The other people in our group were happy with their food as well.

Frankie MacGregor

2020-05

This place is in my mom's home town and in it's first iteration was started by my dearly departed Uncle so I'm a little biased. Had dinner there when I was in town with the whole family. The owner served us. He was very attentive and personable. He successfully balanced tending to the busy phone lines with meeting our needs. The menu has so many great choices that met everyone's needs; gluten free, vegetarian, keto-crust. We ordered fried cheese curds and four or five different pizzas. Everything was tasty and excellent. It's a cherished memory of a family meal that doesn't happen very often.