Sheetz

4.3 (72)

1280 New Creek Hwy, Keyser, WV 26726
(304) 788-1197
orderz.sheetz.com

Claimed
Convenience store
Beer store
Car wash
Coffee shop
Gas station
Restaurant
Wine store
Chain offering fuel & familiar convenience goods, including packaged snacks, drinks & takeaway fare.

Service options

  • Delivery

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Q “Q” Q

2023-05

If it's busy and you are waiting 5-10 minutes for your food, double check it before leaving. Just had one order (put in two, haven't checked the second), and it was missing EVERYTHING I requested on it. I'm not going to bother going back and complain; just letting others know.

Dana Stewart

2023-10

I called the store yesterday regarding a lost credit card. Andy and the staff went above and beyond to help me. Andy checked the safe, and video tape to see if maybe the card was dropped at the pump. Another staff members went out and actively searched the parking lot. These folks all deserve kudos from the store manager for their outstanding efforts. I thank them all from the bottom of my heart.

Josh Bane

2022-05

For probably the 10th time I have order a bucket of fries and got it not even close to being full. If this is the case you shouldn’t bother getting a bucket and just get a cup you get the same amount. Either someone didn’t care or it’s a rip off.

Gary Howell

2024-01

Breakfast sandwich hit the spot!

Adam Cutter

2023-05

I want to give my local Sheetz a 5 but I just can't because of the inconsistency. 95 % of the time I go there I have a positive experience, but that other 5% they are either forgetting simple things from an order, ridding things from their menus, out of stock of several basic items, etc.. but like I said usually the experience is great.

Chris B

2023-07

It's a clean and well maintained Sheetz. Employees are friendly and its a safe place to stop and get gas if you are traveling.

Amanda G.

2022-05

Went in at 7 am Friday, when convenience stores & gas stations are busy with people trying to get to work, plus it was NY eve so it was even more busy. I was pleasantly surprised at how incredibly nice everyone at this store was, despite being incredibly busy. I had asked the lady (Leigh Ann) making subs that I was picking up for lunch later if it were possible to put the toppings on the side. I expected her to be a bit annoyed (the way workers are at my local Sheetz when you ask them pretty much anything) but no.... she was super sweet and said it was no problem, and not only did she put them on the side, but she put each item in its own plastic container (I honestly expected everything to be thrown in 1 single plastic baggy or something). When I went up to check out I was shocked at how friendly the cashier (a blonde hair young man named May? Or Mav?) was, too. I was honestly so surprised with the friendliness of the employees and how accommodating they were that I texted myself their names so I could call later when they weren't busy and let the manager know what great employees they have. I'm in Keyser nearly daily during the week so I will be making it a point to buy my gas and snacks at Sheetz from now on, bc of how great their employees are!

Adam Doolan

2022-05

They got good food when you get it. 2 days in a row I had to wait for almost an hour and I ended up needing to ask about my food. The first time I went inside and ordered and waiting 52 mins and went up and asked where my food was. Best part I said excuse me ma'am at first and the one lady blatantly ignored me and acted like I wasn't there. I finally had to yell and get the attention of a younger girl. They apparently put it over at the pickup area and didn't call the number. They also acted like It was my fault somehow. The 2nd time I did curb side I waited 43 mins and ended up calling. Yet again they said "someone must have picked it up at the pickup area and it wasn't their food." exactly how when it was curb side? It shouldn't have been in the pickup area at all. I gave it 2 stars BECU their chilli dogs are amazing. I'm normally an understanding person BECU I've worked fast food and everything but this tested my patience. But thank you to the two who did help me and get it sorted out.

William yeager

2021-05

This establishment was very clean restrooms included. Coffee was more than half way decent. Love the condiment machines that dispense the creams and sweetners. Doughnuts were fresh even late at night when we stopped.. Keep up the good job👍👍👍

Rosa E Foldi

2023-06

I'm constantly at a Sheetz whether in my home area or out of my town. I purchase all my gas from them and often other items also.

Matt Baker

2022-05

This Sheetz in New Creek W.V. is a well run store. The made to order food is always hot and made to your liking, and the shelves are always well stocked. So stop in and grab yourself a doughnut and a coffee you'll be glad that you did.

Brandon B

2017-05

Nice newer gas station, can get busy at times. I've stopped in 2 or 3 times. Me and the wife got lucky and just beat the lunch rush. Boy did they get slammed. very apologetic about the wait and cashier was pleasant. Not a bad location. Love me some sheetz

Jonah Baksa

2020-05

Exquisite gas, clean pumps, no problems here. Get your gas for cheap, use your sheets card! Ha ha!

Anthony Rogers

2021-05

no real attempt other than employees masked to provide a safe in store environment. always encountering numerous non masked people in line and waiting on the weekends-its crazy- heard it from many

Stacey Dunlap

2023-06

I love Sheetz best to get food and everything else

Barbara Grosse

2023-11

Today was the slowest MTO food ever

David Stewart

2024-04

Clean, attentive staff

Tessa Bruce

2020-05

Kim is seriously the most helpful and kind woman. She went above and beyond to provide amazing customer service. She’s sincerely great.

Nikki

2018-05

Unhelpful, and very slow service, time after time. Don't order ahead online - they'll leave it sitting for over 25 minutes while you stand there waiting on it.

shan orrison

2023-05

I almost got overcharged for a item I purchase regularly, after I complained she rang it up again and the price dropped almost in HALF!!!

Renae Ward

2023-05

Good food and service. Fill up your car and gut at Sheetz.

Duh Chemist

2022-05

Very fast service & wonderful employees. Keep up the great work Sheetz!!!!!!

Carl Judy

2021-05

Always a great place to buy cigs and gas. Plus with the my Sheetz card u can save even more

James Tucker

2023-05

Hot dogs was tow for 1.00 and they were great..

Nate Nickerson

2019-05

Always a smile and good talk with the employees. Fast MTO crew. Clean and Tidy.

Nita Ostroff Tyson

2023-07

Great 4th of july gas special!

Bud Kravchuck

2023-05

Typical Sheetz, clean and always busy

Jerry Smith

2022-05

Food can be hit or miss but overall pretty good

J McCracken

2018-05

Seems the hot dogs have shrunk quiet a bit. Orders were not filled as requested.

Casey kesner

2024-03

So friendly

Opening Hours

Monday Open 24 hours
Tuesday Open 24 hours
Wednesday Open 24 hours
Thursday Open 24 hours
Friday Open 24 hours
Saturday Open 24 hours
Sunday Open 24 hours

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet