Prater's Taters

BARBARA WILSON

2024-05

My husband and I ordered hotdogs. Did not serve as ordered. He ordered fries that came cold. I ordered onion rings that were still cold in the middle from being frozen. Our waitress was almost in tears from the kitchen not keeping up. We saw 3 tables leave after an hr wit for their food. We waited but should have left also. Will not be back.

Anthony Koch

2024-03

Cute decor with Mr 🥔 heads!Food was way better than we thought we both had chicken salad sandwiches and loved them. Wife tried the potato salad and loved it I couldn't due to covid digestive issues going on 2 years! Which is why we finally ate here,I'm finally healthy to eat a sandwich and it didnt disappoint ! Staff was courteous but less than enthused all 4 employees seemed to be having a bad day for from greeting to departure(we said thanks , they ignored us) seemed very intent on slowly make food give it to you then ignore customers but alas it's what most customer service industry employees act like and regardless we will be back food is worth it

Melissa Swingle

2019-05

For a small town restaurant, I think this place is perfection. Yummy food, kid-friendly atmosphere, and good pricing. They even had Mr. Potato Heads on every table for kids to play with. The portion sizes on the baked potatoes were big. They actually give you two baked potatoes on the plate. Also, I grew up on Southeast Idaho and I was very happy to see they use all Idaho potatoes and have a lot of fun memorabilia from Idaho that I always saw as a kid. The staff was friendly and service was great. Two thumbs up!

jessica eddy

2023-11

Absolutely AMAZING food. Only took a star off cause we did a to go order and they forgot my sour cream for my potato and I LOVE sour cream. Hubby isn't as big a potato lover as me and said his bacon and cheese potato was the best he ever had! Also he had the chicken bacon ranch sandwich and gave it 5/5. I had French onion soup which we both agreed was one of the best we have had and I also had the 3 cheese potato which was outstanding (can't wait to try again with sour cream!). We visit the area often and can't wait to go back and try more!

kevin english

2018-05

What a wacky idea for a restaurant! I wasn't sure really what to expect but I like to try the local fare when traveling and I'm really glad I picked this unique place. I had the brisket potato that comes with beef brisket, cheese, sour cream, bacon and crispy onions. The crazy thing was really tasty, I highly recommend this place to those looking for a great locally ran place.

Mitchell Givens

2024-03

…More

Richard Smith

2024-01

…More

Shauna Crane

2022-05

If you LOVE potatoes you have to eat here. They have the best potatoes EVER!!! You will not be disappointed.

Michael Humphrey

2020-05

One of the best places I have ever ate. The quantity of food you get for the price is just unbelievable your plate is just running over. The service was so impeccable they just couldn't do enough to help. One meal can make two.

Melody Anderson

2024-01

…More

Tim Oyer

2023-11

Atmosphere? Well it is what it is when it's in a strip mall.But as for the taters I had the roast beef and cheddar with au jus. It was very good and it was more than I could eat. So hungry I forgot pics. I would recommend eating here for sure. I look forward to coming back someday. They were out cheeseburger loaded potato.

Grant Grathwell

2024-04

…More

Jessica Basham

2023-05

This place was great. I loved the food. If you like baked potatoes they are really good and something for everyone. My kiddos had chicken and pizza.Kid-friendliness: Lots of kid options

Dannielle LaClair

2023-12

…More

Matt Miller

2023-09

…More

Leon Williams

2024-02

…More

Debbie Chandler Green

2023-05

Many, many choices. The potato was great!! Always trying places that are different from the norm.

Helen Roberts-Niemi

2024-02

…More

Kalynn Jacks

2024-03

…More

michael humphrey

2020-05

This places food was so great I cant find all the adjectives to describe how good it is. It's just a place your gonna just have to try on your on. But if you pass up on it you'll just be doing yourself a disservice that your gonna regret.

Ben Monck

2023-06

…More

Mandi Hinton

2024-04

…More

Amy Newman

2024-02

…More

Kyle Mashburn

2021-05

Prater's was a great experience from their options for taters, to the kind service and consideration for the customers before they enter and after they leave.

Joanna Grathwell

2024-04

…More

Noah Bailey

2023-11

…More

Belinda Khidekel

2023-11

Update: I love the Burbon BBQ tater! It is fabulous.Service was friendly but quality of food was not good. Potato was super dry and meat had an old taste, to be fair they close at 8 and I popped in at 7:30 for a to go order. Was my first visit. There won't be a second.

Rachelle Cook

2023-08

I ordered a loaded pull pork potato. The potato was hard the pork was dry and it wasn't hot at all! got one tube of sour cream no chives and no silverware. Ughhh!!! I'm just praying that the salad is good because paying $24.95 for food that isn't worth eating is so upsetting to me! Please do better this is your signature dish and you failed!

Dwayne Duncan

2024-04

…More

Kenneth Ray

2023-05

I love the service and the fact that it is local. I like the food. Their cookies are to die for although I didn't get cookies this time. However I feel like the potatoes are getting smaller and yet the prices are still the same or a bit higher. Also the tater I got today seemed spicy although I didn't get anything that would suggest that it's spicy.