Carlyn's Restaurant

David Hay

2024-04

We decided to do the Lenten specials. We also ordered 2 bowls of soup. When I got home, the paper bag holding one of the soups broke spilling soup everywhere.Then we got a call from them because they screwed up someone's order. My wife mentioned the soup and the owner got on the phone with my wife and blamed me!We will NEVER return.

Kyra M.

2023-10

…More

Bekah Berndt

2023-08

…More

jarrett mccullough

2023-07

I ordered the large chicken parm, thinking it was a meal. It came with 2 small pieces of what seemed to be store bought frozen chicken with a little bit of sauce on it and a slice of cheese. It was supposed to come with a side but they forgot it and to be honestly likely would have been a very small salad if I would have gotten it based on the portion size of the rest of this "meal". For $14 I expected more, similar restaurants in the area you can get the chicken parm dinner with spaghetti, salad and garlic bread for $12-$14. I bought 2 of these unfortunately and walked out of there spending $29 for 4 pieces of chicken barely covered in sauce. A friend got the spaghetti and it had very little sauce on it, very dry. Would not recommend this restaurant. Also if you do decide to order, don't bother leaving a name for your order as I was told they dont write names down, so they instead shuffle through the order forms after asking specifically what you ordered, the pickup process was a hot mess.Parking: Tight parking situation and few spots at that

Melanie Klesyk

2024-04

…More

Brandon Shaw

2023-05

Food was standard for that type of restaurant. Waitress was “just helping” because they didn’t have staff. The owner or manager whoever it was, continuously yelled at elderly customers as they attempted to pay their bill. We witnessed this twice before decided to leave. So I guess if you’re in the mood for decent food you can try this place, but I wouldn’t take any elderly relatives.

Kitty Powell

2023-05

We came in not long before closing. My young son was so taken by the staff. The food was great, and the staff made him so happy and full. We will definitely be going back. Thank you for a great meal and a happy boy.

iami 77

2023-05

I just ordered the broiled chicken with baked potato. Chicken was so good, juicy and tender and the baked potato was cooked perfectly! Loved my food!

Brenda Christy

2023-05

I went in to get my meal for take out , Chicken parmesan and it was delicious 😋 😊. They definitely give you enough to eat . I will definitely go back. And the staff is very nice and friendly..

Tina Faint

2022-05

Amazing home made food! Great service! Can’t wait to go back! Serving size is large & taste amazing! Fresh salads, home made sauce…..The owners make sure you are well taken care of & takes pride in her cooking. AWSoME place! ❤️ It

Margie Wagner

2024-02

…More

Terrie McCombs

2023-12

…More

Diane Olenik

2022-05

I heard Wonderful things about Carlyn's till I ate there today. I order the Stuffed Haddock with Crab Meat Stuffing. It was the Frozen Entree you buy at The Super Market during Lent. It was over Cooked. Well 33.00 dollars later I went Home Hungry.. Sincerely....Diane Geddes Olenik. Yes, a Windber Girl.

Nancy Werner

2022-05

Had lasagna...not too bad, but meatballs were not fresh...had that reheated flavor. This restaurant could use a thorough cleaning...soiled carpeting and sticky table tops.

mary thomas

2022-05

The service was bad. It was busy but did have a reservation, party of 16, we got our food at different times, very disorganized. Some of the food was cold & wrong orders. Then when directly asked, the person was honest. The person asking was very rude.

Kathy Beam (KATYB53)

2022-05

Been there several times. This was one of Mom's favorites! The food is always good and homemade, people are friendly and the prices aren't bad.

charles wright

2022-05

Great family owned business. Home cooked meals. Not as well known as a few of the more popular restaurants in Windber but better food at better prices in my opinion.

Gary Mosholder

2023-05

…More

adamtr1121

2022-05

I’ve have ate there a few times, the food was good.

Dave Swinger

2022-05

Great food and great service. Definitely recommend eating here.

Jim Rey

2022-05

The Chicken Cacciatore is amazing..Will definitely be back for more.

Mike Gindlesperger

2023-05

Brayden the cook did a excellent job as always!!!

Robert Senft

2023-05

…More

Dan Miller

2024-02

…More

John

2022-05

Great food and the service was awesome.

Old Dirtball

2023-05

Great food and personable staff.

R Howard

2023-05

Rehearsal dinner gathering was awesome!

Edward Friedel

2023-05

Great food and good service

Gwen gamble

2023-05

Not near as good as usual, disappointed

TAS 467

2023-05

Excellent meatballs and sauce!!