Pague & Fegan True Value

Jenn Shinaberger

2020-05

Great little hardware store that’s a nice alternative to the big box stores. There is so much stuff, that I’m not sure how they fit it in there. Every thing is neat and orderly. We went for rubber stoppers and they had six different sizes and they directed us right to them. If you want that small town, back-in-the-day feel with friendly service then this is your place.

Joshua Auman

2023-07

If you need something 95% chance is they have it. I needed parts for under my bathroom sink and wow they had the part I needed. When I needed parts for a cast iron tube they had them when I couldn't find parts anywhere else. A contractors go to when needing that item you can't find somewhere else. The staff are very helpful and great with kids. I recommend them 100%

Steve Dawson

2023-11

Love the feeling of an old time hardware store. The staff were very friendly and helpful with showing me where everything I needed was located!!

danny k

2023-05

They have about everything you would need. Great small town family owned business. If its something obscure that you cant find chances are they have it. A little more expensive than big box stores but it's worth it to support a great small town business. They're always really helpful with anything you need or cant find. Worth checking out for sure.

Dan Turner

2023-05

This is the kind of place that every town should have... and probably, back in the day, almost every town did have. Shop local and show your appreciation for a good old-fashion hardware store that carries modern wares at a good price. Thanks to the management for providing such a community resource.

Ty Ditch

2023-10

Had to pick up some batteries and thay didnt have them in stock so thay were nice enough to order them for me. Thanks guys

Jacki Whistler

2022-05

Appears small on the outside. I expected to spend a maximum of 5 minutes to browse the whole store looking for what I needed. Spent close to 20 minutes. Store goes deep into the building. I expected a few main items in each category (nails, plumbing, electrical, etc.) I was pleasantly surprised that I didn't need to go to Lowes (as I had expected to not find my specific item) they had lots of all kinds of supplies. I now found my go to hardware store and it's a 5 minute drive rather than a 15-20 minute drive.

Billy Russell

2022-05

I just love this hardware store, it puts Lowe's and Home Depot to shame. If they don't have it, it can't be had!! Just bought a new General portable generator for under $700.

Trevor Smith

2022-05

My friend and I are highly impressed by the professionalism exhibited by the staff at Pague & Fegan. We shipped a tabletop slot machine through them, via FedEx, which we sold on eBay for $1,600, back in September. When the item was delivered, the buyer (who even signed for the package) lied, and claimed that the item was not as described, and damaged prior to shipment (3 months after the fact). This wasn’t even remotely true, of course, but that’s eBay buyers in a nutshell. The employee who packed the item was more than happy/willing to work with us to help resolve the problem, by providing a written statement, and signature, confirming that the item wasn’t damaged at all prior to shipment, which was/is greatly appreciated, and will be immensely helpful in terms of proving the buyer is being dishonest and damaged the item himself, which we would have otherwise been held responsible for. We will definitely be shipping items from this location in the future. Thanks again, Andrew!

Dan Fritts

2022-05

Amazing what this store has for being downtown! I've always been able to find what I need at a fair price. Staff usually very helpful but the last couple of times not quite as helpful.

Matthew Frost

2021-05

Best place to get hardware parts in an old fashioned way really nice place the store is old but there stuff is great they have stuff I have look for a long time. Best experience in shopping in a long timeThanksI will check here before I go anywhere else. No more big box stores for me endless Pague & Fegan doesn't have it.

Tom Murry

2022-05

This place always seems to have all those little things that you can't find anywhere else. Probably best to start here because if you can't find it here you're probably not finding it anywhere else locally either. Staff always very helpful and will take as much time as they need to help you find what you're looking for.

Eric Fenderson

2021-05

Pague and Fegan is a great little hardware store. I've been going there almost 20 years. I've purchased everything from a single fender washer to a new pistol. The last 2 times I went in, none of the employees were wearing masks. Last time, I asked the employees to put them on, and they said "we don't do that here". In such a small, tight space, it's unconscionable. I won't be back.

c r martin

2023-05

Fantastic helpers work here . Found me the correct shower control valve parts and gave me good advice on how to remove the old one. Great people

Jennifer Monn

2023-05

Great True Value dealer Great service and friendly staff Mike and Kevin are keeping a Shippensburg treasure alive and well! Check them out! 😊And they offer federal express services!!

kismet pa

2014-05

This is one of my favorite places to visit when I go to Shippensburg! This is the hardware store that time forgot. They have EVERYTHING you could imagine...even items that haven't been made in decades. Prices are pretty reasonable on most items, the staff is helpful and it's a great place to just look around for awhile. We found corks that fit antique jugs here...think like 2" wide...and we'd looked for years for large corks. If you are looking for something and can't find it, give Pague & Fegan a try...you might be surprised what all they have!

Janet Haggard

2022-05

A true handy person's store. They have EVERYTHING. Plumbing, tools, gardening, paint, windows; anything you could need for home repairs. And the staff is very helpful.

nate gulnac

2023-05

Workers are very helpful locating whatever you need to find in the store, if in stock...

Douglas Layton

2023-05

A great little hardware store. Has saved me a lot of time and money while working in Shippensburg, seems they have one of about anything.

Peace Miller

2019-05

Very good service. The employees there are very helpful and knowledgeable. I've gone in, explained what am trying to work on for my diy projects and they will direct me on what I need. Very helpful. I love this store.

carol Mcintosh

2023-05

These men that run this store, are very accommodating and are very respectful. Go see what they have.

Jason Goshorn

2022-05

This place has a wide variety of hardware. Anything from nuts and bolts to caulking and even cuts glass for you. Highly recommend. Also great customer service and focus.

Kay Bear

2019-05

Pague and Fegan has it been in my life since I was very young. I moved away from Shippensburg around the age of 21. But every time I come back to that town I stopped at Pague and Fegan because I love that store takes back with memories. I just love an old hardware stores, and this is one of the best. Every little book and cranny of the store has bits and pieces of everything from toys to sink parts, chains to flags for your porch.. very nice young men work there too. They offered to carry your things out to the car. How long has it been since that happened to you? When you're in Shippensburg stop at Pague and Fegan and get a treat.

Joe Mackey

2023-05

This place always has everything you need when it comes to your home not very much Automotive stuff I'm sure you can find what you need

Kyle Shoop

2018-05

Used the fedex ground drop off which is very convenient. Had to wait a while for someone to come to the counter, but the fedex employee was helping other customers at the time and needed to finish with them first.

Charles Pyatt

2023-05

Awesome store that has an incredible inventory and friendly helpful staff 👍👍

Lavon Weaver

2019-05

THIS IS !! the place to go if you want good service in a small town setting..something you wont find at the big box stores. If you have the choice choose this place. You wont be disappointed..

Erica Miller

2022-05

Amazing selection of just about anything you can imagine, and very helpful & friendly staff.

Logic

2022-05

Hometown hardware at its best! If they don't have it or know how to get it, you don't need it. Love this place!

Justin Gallo (PropainterJ)

2022-05

The guys in here are always extremely helpful in finding me whatever it is I need. Highly recommend for any contractor or do it yourselfer 👍