The Broken Arrow Cafe’

Cassandra Couchenour

2024-04

…More

Terry Powers

2024-04

Food -excellent..large portionsStaff-top shelf ..very attentive..polite & friendlyTalk to “Butch”.. the owner..down to earth..hard working, just trying to make a honest dollar..Heard pies were good..ice cream coming soon. ..Prices ..Very FairDont miss the stop !!!A Big Lunch for 6 Adults and 2 takeouts was under $70...All of us needed boxes to take our food home ...You Guys Rock !!!Parking: Big Parking lot..we are county folk ..no charge

Mark Jones (Jeep)

2024-04

So...if you are watching your waistline avoid this place... portions are huge and delicious... atmosphere is great as are the patrons... exceptional wait staff... these gals bust butt and make sure you are taken care of. This "Blizzard" had more Reese's stuff in it than ice cream...I couldn't even finish it after the bacon cheeseburger I had.... everyone at our table was beyond happy with our dining experience.Kid-friendliness: Our little ones can be a tad loud from time to time, but no one seemed to be offended ...and the kids portion were very generous...not like some kids menu items from other eating establishments.

Joe Vogel

2023-11

…More

Dennis Pennington

2024-02

…More

Brandie Ross

2023-10

…More

Charlene Jewart

2023-10

…More

Larissa Owen

2023-10

The food tasted homemade! It wasn't super crowded either, so it was nice to sit down and be able to relax as a family. The portions were large for the price.Kid-friendliness: They had a kids menu.

justin h

2024-04

…More

Todd Peace

2023-05

…More

Faintly Artistic

2024-01

…More

Eric Gilbert

2023-07

Amazing food and portions, wonderful staff (thank you very much Mikayla!) And a super cute diner, definitely appeals to hunters and country living. Very highly recommend!

Jason Arnold

2024-02

…More

Donna Glunt

2023-10

…More

Ed Slonka Jr

2024-02

…More

Heather E

2023-05

Such a cute restaurant in the middle of a small town. I got a chance to speak with the owner today and he was telling me how they opened their doors in 2020 and weeks later they were mandated to close due to Covid- inspite of all the trials of 2020, the restaurant survived!The pies are made fresh in the restaurant. The ingredients are fresh, and their coffee is hot. I stopped in for a work meeting and they kindly brought me coffee and waited until after the meeting to take my order. I had a simple order, one BLT but, which was perfect- it was the first time I ate a blt in a restaurant where the bacon was not severely over cooked.The wait staff was kind and understanding. I did not feel rushed while I took up a table for a little more time than usual, had my laptop open for work while I waited for my food.This was a welcomed stop on a path a little less traveled- but one I will be happily making again.If you want some small town charm, take a stroll through Mahaffey to find this hidden gem, it's located right off of the 219.Wheelchair accessibility: The parking and entry is wheelchair accessible.

Greg Giardina

2023-11

…More

John Testa

2023-10

…More

allen coble

2023-07

…More

John Lloyd

2023-07

…More

Cassidy Rowles

2023-09

$16 for 2 large ice cream cones..and the one was practically only one scoop.

Lynette Hurd

2023-09

…More

Doug Brink

2023-08

…More

urmama66

2023-05

The prices are a bit much for the small town it's located in, pay 13-16$ for a special. If the food was out of this world maybe, but it's mediocre.

Ray Kauffman

2023-05

…More

Ken Coleman

2023-10

…More

Bethany Coover

2023-07

…More

Steveand Paula

2024-03

…More

Vince Greggi

2023-05

…More

Dawne Davis

2023-05

…More