Tomaselli's Pastry Mill & Cafe

Mitch Newbury

2024-03

…More

Adam G-Mann

2023-12

They have really good bakery treats! They have a wode selection to choose from, and everything is always made fresh that day. There is also a discounted area for day old items, which are not to be underestimated either. I stop here every time on my way to Coos Bay for a coffee or tea pick me up and something delicious. So good. Highly recommend!

Missy Padilla Runyon

2024-02

I've noticed this place several times going through Elkton, and we finally made it in. Wow! It's wonderful, and as luck would have it I was given a freshly baked molasses chocolate chip cookie sprinkled with Himalayan salt. For lunch I had the tri-tip steak salad special, which came with the freshest French bread on the side, and a yummy amber beer to wash it down. They also have a helluva bakery section, and my husband raved about the cinnamony bear claw. We left with several pastries, a loaf of sourdough rye bread, a dozen cookies, and a vow to stop in again soon. EDIT: Today my husband was in a hurry but needed lunch. I called 15 minutes before he was going to be in Elkton, and they put the chicken pot pie in early so it would be ready when he got there. Love this place!

Joshua James

2023-06

I came fir a grilled cheese sandwich and left with a bag of baked goods. The sandwich was great and the first grilled cheese I have had with a side of salsa for dipping. It paired great together. There were some very good pastries as well!

Prasad Sanjay

2022-05

We love Tomaselli's! Everything tastes special and unique! 😋 The bakery is to die for! We can't resist the danishes, turnovers and cookies! We tried their pizza this time and it was a great decision!The staff is always warm and welcoming! This particular trip Natalie helped us. She was genuinely welcoming, charismatic and hospitable! She made us feel like we came to visit an old friend!From stopping there on the way to soccer games in the 90's or on my visit home from college in the 00's this is was a mandatory stop for our family. We made new memories with our kiddos!

Linda Rochon

2024-04

There were about 15 ladies for a birthday party luncheon.They did a wonderful job of accommodating us. We had several types of pizza, wine and cheesecake. Food, service, space was perfect. We will be back. Thank you.Vegetarian options: Their gluten free veggies pizza was wonderful.

Anna Perry

2024-03

…More

Ty Davis

2023-07

Stopped in on our way from Medford to the Oregon Coast.Got some jalapeño jerky, a sour cream pocket with apricot jam, and an elkton pie. All were outstanding.We have a child with severe egg and nut allergies, and they were good about telling us what she could and couldn’t have. Quick note - there aren’t but a couple of things that don’t have egg. This includes the jerky…which is really tasty.Overall - the ladies inside are awesome and the food was totally worth the stop in this little town.

Millie Ben-David

2024-05

Good draft beer selection but the pizza was terrible. They have other items on the menu but I didn’t get a chance to eat any of them.Vegetarian options: Plenty of optionsDietary restrictions: GF pizza

Ron Woodhead

2021-05

2019: Terrific lunch stop with varied menu. Amazing cookies, fresh from the oven! Yum.UPDATE April 2021: Another enjoyable lunch, this time while motorcycle touring through the area. Terrific sandwiches and perfect dessert baked goods. Keep up the great work!

Kevin K

2024-02

…More

Todd Richardson

2020-05

Stopped here for lunch the ratings were 4.5. I had a choker setter sandwich which I believe to be cross between roast beef and pastrami that you couldn't bite through. My wife had the cheeseburger which tasted like a meatloaf sandwich. Not that Meatloaf bad but this wasn't good. The place was clean and had quite a variety to look at. But they were unprepared for a lunch run on a Friday which shows in their food! The place was only 1/3 full and maybe half full by the time we left. Thought about getting something from the bakery but was left so unimpressed from lunch decided not to order anything to go. Should try to come back and maybe do breakfast and dinner to do a full review but at this point I may have to abstain. I do you have to say the beer selection was very good.

Ericka A

2023-05

Nice little breakfast and bakery place. We found gluten free and vegan option as well. But the super yummy homemade pastries that had all the gluten and dairy was really was incredible

Dgv11

2023-08

$16 cheeseburger was very small and on a very dry bun. Not good. Fries burnt ends and seems like baked frozen out of a bag. Pastry very good but expensive. $4 turnover. Overall, overpriced for bad food (except pastry which is just over priced).

Steve Wilson

2024-03

…More

Wendy Bliss

2022-05

Sourdough French toast is ahhhhhhmazing! Well, pretty much everything they have is. We come to town every year and this is the first.. second....third, stop we make ! Grab a big cinnamon roll for the road. Yum!!

Kelly Furtado

2023-05

We absolutely loved this place. The food was great and the service was superb. We took a bag home from their bakery too.

Jeanie D

2023-05

We have had lunch at Tomaselli's, and now, tonight, their delicious wood fire pizza. Absolutely wonderful food!! All in house made breads, dressings, the works. So, so good! And so reasonably priced. Do not miss it!!

Kat4cats

2023-09

This has been our favorite place between Eugene and the coast for years. But, it isn't just because of the location. Their food is amazing! I have never been disappointed. Ever. Our last trip to Elkton, we were there for the day. We had breakfast and then, later before we left, pizza. Everything was delicious and perfectly prepared. There were 4 in our party and we all felt the same way.Our friends had special dietary constraints, and they accommodated them beautifully. Our friends were extremely happy with the way they worked to give them what they wanted, and to have it look and taste so good too!They also have homemade pastries, which are worth the stop in and of themselves. You will not be sorry you stopped here!!

William Berdusco

2023-07

Absolutely incredible. We happened to pass by on one journey but I would travel out of my way for this next time. The Sicilian pizza is no lie the best pizza I've had in my life. Like an Italian sandwich in pizza form. The service was awesome, food was awesome, environment was awesome. An actual 10/10. If you're reading this review and debating it. I'm telling you it's worth it.

Briana Snyder

2023-08

Had breakfast w/my family here. I got a country scramble which was hot, fresh & the biscuits were homemade. My partner & daughter got French toast. The berry compote was fresh and no syrup or whipped cream needed. All the staff were so kind. Be sure to stop in here before making your way to the sand dunes or back towards Portland.

Tony LaMorticella

2023-06

Out of the way but actually very conveniently located halfway between the valley and the coast, and right on the spectacular Umpqua River. I have eaten here several times and have tried a good part of their menu, and every meal I've had here has been superb. As if that wasn't enough, the people who work here are lovely, they provide very pleasant seating both indoor and outdoor, and all of their baked goods are excellent.

Dave Silva

2020-05

Travelling through Elkton. Found this place had avery disfunctional counter/service staff.Ordered a Cuban and it was supposed to come on ciabatta but came on but look like a cut baguette. the baguette was good quality but we ordered the one from the menu with a ciabatta. onion and pickle and cheese was good but pork felt like leftover reheated meat.Order pie alamode mode but they brought me just pie because they said their ice cream had gone over.Asked for a side of ranch but was not given. Paid extra for the fries quantity and quality were not up to par (see pictures).Had to asked for silverware multiple times. Was told they would bring water but that never happened. When we went in to ask for water we were told to bring it back in when we were done.The Cuban was really lacking in mustard. Would have asked for more, but by now I was really done with this place.There attitude ran high here!!! Service was terrible!!!PS No toilet paper in restroom *rolls eyes*

Sorefinger Records

2024-03

…More

Mark Oda

2023-11

…More

Beverly Roberts

2018-05

Best food I have ever ate!! Quiet atmosphere, very friendly staff. The owner came out visited with us, very friendly. Definitely recommend it to others.

James Hershiser

2023-05

When I accidentally left my credit card behind, they took the time to find my info and mail it back to me because they would be closed. Really amazing of them to do that, thank you! and the food is always great too.

Lisa Anderson

2023-05

Hidden Gem!!! What a wonderful find this little cafe and bakery is. Great cinnamon rolls. Several vegetarian options. Many of the ingredients are organic and/or locally sourced. Good beer and wine options. Didn't try the coffee--yet. We'll be back.

leonor willis

2023-05

Great bread and I had a glass of the Chardonnay (from California). My chicken pot pie was more a hearty vegetable chicken soup with a pastry topping. Didn't care for it. My other companions were satisfied with their meals. I would like to try their breakfast but will be leaving before I get the chance.

Julaine Haraden Morley

2023-05

I didn't dine here, but took away some pastries. The cinnamon twist was delicious, and their take on an Oreo - 2 chocolate cookies with buttercream between - was a decadent delight. My husband found the apple turnover to be overly sweet, largely due to an abundance of glaze. If I lived in the area, I'd go back to try something on the menu.