Out of This World Collectibles

MkMG09

2023-05

- staff friendly and knowledgeable.- place clean and organized even know it a little store.- prices not bad for most items.- store has a nice selection of different items for sale, you can also sell them certain items if they are interested in what you have.Parking is not hard to find but a little limited if the area is busy.- overall a nice little store to visit if you are into Funko's, action figures etc.- I'd recommend this location.

Jared Hoppel

2023-07

Take a trip down memory lane at this fun little store! Get your nostalgia fix and then some.Very reasonable prices and super friendly staff.If you're a collector or just happen to be in the area it's definitely worth a visit.

Frank

2024-02

James and Sonja are amazing. Friendly, family oriented business. I have been holding on to my childhood Star Wars toys for over 40 years. I know I took it to the correct place. James gave me a very fair deal for all I had, and even threw in a few Legos for my 5 year old son. I highly recommend going here if you are looking to buy or sell vintage toys.

Phantom Tales

2023-05

My wife and I absolutely love this collectables store,The owner makes us feel welcome and his little dog boba fett is too cute not to pet. We have gotten our most prized items from here.

Jennifer Vandergriff

2022-05

Absolutely love this store. It's located in downtown Pataskala and is such a neat find. My son loves the choose your own Legos by the pound bins and the Lego figure bin. Seeing the Spiderman outside made our day. Will be back to do a trade in or 3.

Leon J Ingram

2023-05

If you like the 80's toys, this place will take you back! Great shop and the owner is very, very helpful, knowledgeable and most importantly, friendly. My son and I will make more trips to this shop!

Jonah Goerlitz

2024-03

Awesome selection of cool retro toys. Employees are super nice. Great deals.

L1 Muzz

2023-10

Best Toy store in the Central Ohio and the surrounding area! hands down! I've been doing business with the owner for 25+ years and this store is the culmination of his many years of experience!You will not find a more knowledgeable expert in the field.The staff is friendly and helpful, the selection is always changing and always awesome! Be sure to check this store out!

Steve Detillion

2023-10

This is one of those awesome stores if you are feeling a little nostalgic. The store owner is kind and super friendly/knowledgeable. They will pay a fair rate for vintage toys you may have laying around. Worth it to check this place out if you are looking for that specific piece from your childhood.

Torie Schaeffer

2023-07

We love this toy shop! We make a point to stop in when we visit the area from ID. The people are amazing and very friendly. They are very knowledgeable. We love the furry little helper (They have a dog.) We have made it a yearly tradition to pop in. You never know what treasures you'll find there.

Grant Kessler

2022-05

Picked up these two Star Wars collectible signs. Got to talk to the owner and play with their dog! They were welcoming and a pleasure to do business with.

Mike Bryan

2022-05

Fantastic collectibles shop! Owner is very personable and knows his stuff! So much to look at in there! So worth the trip! You can even take pictures with Spidey out front!

A Ash

2024-02

Was pleasantly surprised by the selection in this shop. Glad I stopped buy. I recommend for anyone

anthony smith

2023-07

Had intentions of spending some money here. However, the clerk that was one duty was completely rude. Apparently wasn't happy with me having a 5-year-old with me. Just be prepared kids aren't really wanted in the shop they act like you can't touch anything I will say they have a very nice selection and collection of things. It will take you back. Prices are at there highest value!! I will visit the store again. Hopefully the same clerk isn't working because he was a jerk

Rina

2023-05

This place instantly took me back to my childhood. Nothing else matters when you walk into this store. The owners are so nice. What an incredible place to be to press pause on life, reflect on some of the best times of our lives and dream again. The Spiderman standing outside gives me life every time I pass it.

Kristi Beckham

2023-05

We’ve passed that spider man many times before I finally agreed to stop and explore the shop with my kiddos. I’m glad we did. My kids were encouraged to take good care of their toys and keep their Lego pieces together. They were taught a bit about the trade-in concept.With help from the owner, was also able to secretly make a purchase behind their backs (for Christmas) because they were so into the many things to look at.I’m sure we will be back!

danielle rajca

2023-05

Wow where do I start?! These are some of the best business owners out there! They love their customers and make sure every piece that comes through their shop is ready to go and for people to enjoy. They have such rare items and are so helpful while in the store. My family and I consider them good friends now! ❤️ and thank you for always having batteries in the toys!

Frank Long

2023-11

Great place for vintage and collectable toys. Even a few rare games and puzzles. If interested in games just ask to see more.

Kelly Dillbeck

2024-01

I love the people that work there everyone was so nice and accommodating to me because I'm in a wheelchair

Hanna Sanders

2023-05

Out of This World Collectibles is one of our favorite stores to visit! We live over an hour away and make the drive to go to this store every couple months. The owners are fantastic people and are always so welcoming! They are very fair with buying collections if you're looking to sell. If you're looking to buy, they have a great selection of collectibles and Funko pops. You will always find something you didn't know you needed! I can't say enough good things about this place! Highly recommend! I wish there were more stores like yours!

Meredith Harrison

2023-05

We visited for the first time today and my 7 girl was in heaven. They have a wild verity of toys and collectibles; from fan favorites to rare hard to fine treasures. They also have something to fit everyone budget. WE WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK!!

Erica Hannah

2022-05

This shop has a huge collection of toys ranging from different decades and sitting at different price points. One of the many things I love about this store is how organized it is. Everything has a place. You won't find a shelf that seems cluttered. The selection is displayed very neatly so you can easily find what you are looking for. Not one item looks resold. Every toy I looked at appeared as if it was brand new. They also just recently started selling Pokémon cards individually, which my son loves to browse through. The owners are so friendly and welcoming and make the shopping experience truly enjoyable. They also have the cutest store mascot! Highly recommend this shop!

Blaze Doug

2022-05

Awesome little shop, that's jam packed with goodies. Beyond that, they're just great people. We stopped by to look around, and our son really wanted one of the Jurassic World lego figures. We looked through those they had already bagged and separated, and couldn't find one. But the owner then offered to dig out a tote full of unsorted ones he had in the back. And then even helped us in our search. Took a little doing, but we were able to put together the exact figure our son wanted! Will definitely be back.

Troy Thorpe

2024-03

Great spot for hard to find collectibles. Staff is friendly.

Cereth Painting

2023-05

Amazing store and amazing owners. They have a lot of everything and we are so happy to have you in Pataskala!Just purchased a grail item…the alien queen! Price was waaaaay better than any of the online options. James is great!

Paul Campbell

2023-05

Great selection of toys. Super helpful and friendly. Pricing is where is should be. I really enjoy going into this store. I have NOTHING but great things to say about this store and it’s employees and owners. The Spider-Man out front is just the first super cool thing about the place.

James L

2023-10

Really cool store with a lot of great products! Owner was very nice and had good prices

Sara Coello

2023-07

The owner was very patient and kind toward our young children while they looked around the store, he even threw in some candy with our purchase! It made their day! We will be returning again soon!

Samantha Etzler

2022-05

Out of this World Collectibles is one of the best collectible stores in the Columbus area! James and Sonya are some of the kindest people who treat everyone who comes through their store like family! If you are in need of any collectible you can think of go check out their store! They have an amazing selection! My favorite place to go to find that missing piece from my collection!

Bryon Mcguinness

2023-05

The only thing cool about this place is the Spider-Man statue out front...Owner was rude acted like since i was from out of town he didnt want to help me. Most items in the store was priced well above ebay pricing or right at. Yeah i understand rarity and overhead but nuthing was that uncommon to find in the place and the things i asked about he said he had but didnt want to sale so im not sure what business ethics that was only to push me out the door as fast as he could but thats ok i wont be back to this hole in the wall place nor if i see the name at a show i wont stop in the booth..kindness and professionalism goes a long way in business not money and greed