Fairport Harbor Creamery

sherron j.

2024-04

We had the salted chocolate chip cookies and a milkshake. Oh!! We were blown away!! The fresh taste, soft cookie, thick milkshake with a extra wide straw for help😊. Our next trip here we plan to try the homemade ice cream ccokie!! The inside was clean, welcoming and staff were very inviting. A must see when ypu travel to Fairport Harbor, Ohio

Joshua Korth

2023-11

So many delicious, inventive flavors! The ice cream and baked goods are equally good. Service is always great and friendly. And they have Boozy milkshakes! (& Dole Whip, for those who can't have ice cream, or just want something lighter.) Whether buying a sampler, Sundae, or pints to go, you can't go wrong here!

Kelly Palmer

2023-08

This place is amazing!! I love that they have flats, so you can try 4 different flavors. They have ice cream, boozy ice cream, and dole whip. The dole whip was so refreshing. The baked goods look and taste amazing. Service was friendly and inviting. Super clean!! The upstairs was a nice area to relax and eat your ice cream. I also loved the photographs posted.

Kristen Wheeler

2024-04

The ice cream is AWESOME! If you've never been you should go! They have so many options. We highly recommend the sampler. It is cheap and it gives you a variety of 4 different ice creams to pick from. The environment is historic and the location is great!Parking: Parking on location and nearby street spots.Kid-friendliness: Yes!

Pam Pierce

2024-04

Excellent homemade ice cream and homemade cookies all year round. May have other items some times. Some unusual treats, like raspberry chocolate brownie, pistachio ice cream. Very nice place and people. A bit small, it will be crowded in the summer. Also provides food for parties and a freezer full of sundaes. They make most anything you ask for - shakes, malts, sundaes, etc. But do NOT give tastes. I was very disappointed by that since I have little idea if I will like it or not without tasting it. They have a dish of 4 individual ice cream scoops, which we bought to try multiple flavors at once.

Ben Spitz

2024-03

I’ve spent way more money than I care to admit here over the past six months. I don’t regret a penny of it. The service and environment are both wonderful, but the ice cream itself is even better. By far the most flavorful, creamy, unique ice cream I’ve ever had.

Nancy Reinhardt

2024-03

Awesome staff, the best ice cream, and our favorite place regardless of the season! We love the chocolate, lighthouse, and PB Oreo flavors. Can't beat the lake views either

Karen

2024-03

…More

Ashley Harris-Jackson

2023-05

My 1st time going here and it was so pretty on the inside. They had many different flavors and fresh cookies as well. I got the blueberry cheesecake milkshake and my daughter got some chocolate and vanilla ice cream. And not to mention its right on the Harbor. Literally in walking distance.

Dennis Capp

2023-05

Fantastic! Grabbed a Ship-face milkshake and pint of pistachio. Taste super yummy. Would definitely recommend checking this place out. Will be back very soon. Update 5/7/22 have come back multiple times and never disappointed. Service is fast, efficient and friendly. Everything is great here from ice cream to cookie sandwiches to milkshakes. Would give 10 stars if I could.

Mindy Lucido

2023-12

…More

Lauren Hovan Moore

2023-05

Ice cream and bakery (both sweet and savory) are phenomenal. Staff is pleasant. The cinnamon rolls at Christmastime are unbelievable. I haven’t had a bad piece of bakery or bad flavor of ice cream yet. Location is gorgeous. I’m a weekly visitor year-round 😁 keep up the great work, thank you!!

Alexis Orr

2024-03

…More

Heather Heston

2023-05

I'm a pumpkin spice fan (not sorry!), so I wanted to try one of their seasonal pumpkin ice creams! Pumpkin Chai doesn't disappoint! Yum! My husband picked Butter Pecan ice cream and it's got lots of large pecans in it!We also got a Blueberry Maple Scone and a Cardamom Honey Biscuit that comes with a side of sweetened cream cheese and their housemade strawberry jam. We shared both and enjoyed them!You can eat there or order online to go. If you're in the area (Fairport beach and lighthouse are a stones throw away!), I'd encourage you to stop by!

Jordan Levy

2022-05

Ice cream is made on location, as are pastry and delicious baked goods.I wish they offered samples, but if I didn't like the flavor the owner said she'd make a new one. I got a fudge sundae ($5.25) with mocha and salted caramel. It was delicious!I've been back several times since my initial review and the ice-cream is always good. They have added boozy shakes, which are OK, but I prefer their normal offerings.During the Covid19 outbreak, the inside part of the restaurant is closed, but there is a newly added walkup window. Outside seating consists of 8 or so tables, but on warm nights they fill up fast.

Dana W

2021-05

5 starsx2!!! 1st...the girl working tonight was AMAZING! 2nd....they have GREAT dairy free options! 3rd...you can buy a sampler and sample 4 flavors for 5 bucks!!! Not to mention its a great building with a great view!!! We will be back...TOMORROW!!!

David Schindler

2020-05

This is a Fairport Harbor instant classic. We had a big group that ended up trying most of their menu. It's a bit upscale with both the ice cream and pasteries made fresh in house. Pumpkin Spice milkshake was seasonal and delicious. The "hidden menu" ice cream sandwiches were to die for...try the salty chocolate chip cookies with cookies and cream ice cream. You won't regret it.

Google Reviewer

2021-05

This place is amazing. I just wish they'd open back up the inside. Everything else is open now. Or at least display you're pastries so we could know what to order. But the ice cream is amazing. We went multiple times in our weekend stay, I can't wait to return.

Victor Santana Jr.

2023-05

NEW FAVORTIE DESSERT PLACE ALERT! Super cute establishment plus location is cute also. Nice outdoor area to sit and eat. Little park/lake down the road(1/4 mile walk). Definitely recommend if you are in the area!We had the Buckeye Milkshake that was good. But the Boozie Milkshake were the hidden gems to this place. You can add alcohol to any dessert! We had the Ship-Faced... was super good!Will be back!

Yinan Wang

2024-04

…More

Barbara Gifford

2023-06

What’s a summer afternoon without ice cream? The fun boozy mixes are oh so yummy! I absolutely love this place!

Jessica Flerchinger

2022-05

The day I have something bad from here is the day the apocalypse has come. The homemade ice cream is incredible, their pastries (both sweet and savory kinds) pies/cakes and cookies are all out of this world. They are constantly coming up with new ice cream flavors and you are able to buy pints to bring home. They also offer special ice cream pies and cakes for all sorts of holidays all year long. The location at the top of the hill overlooking Lake Erie is also beautiful ❤️.

Taylor Henry

2024-03

…More

Shonika Fair

2023-10

Found on a whimb because another spot was closed. The ice cream was amazing! It was so nice, the two ladies were very nice, the place was adorable and very clean and had the best view of the Harbor! I'll be back to try some other treats!

Kathy

2022-05

What a find! Ice cream made there with boozy ice options? Umm....yes please! So yummy! Will definitely make a trip back soon. Love the walk up window and outdoor seating. Friendly staff too!

Kristy Jenkins

2023-09

Finally made the drive out from Lorain. Did not disappoint. Fast, friendly service. A variety of fairly priced, fresh and tasty treats. Adorably restored storefront. Ample seating. They hit all the marks.

Connie Kinkelaar

2023-05

It was very good. The ice cream was very good. I will go back it again. You can go out side and sit down and watch the sunset.

Jason Kartesz

2021-05

What an amazing experience this is! Quite possibly the best ice cream I have had anywhere, ever! I am about average when it comes to loving ice cream, but I could literally gorge myself on everything here! Worth the drive from Erie, PA area! #datenightidea

Gramm Me

2023-05

They always have fresh ice cream and they make it there. They also have pup cups with plain vanilla ice cream. My kids and dogs love when we go.

B G

2024-03

Years of suffering at the hands of Big Sugar and all the temptations. Yes, there are too many things to try - it is simply unfair that one cannot eat it all. You have to fight your way past the salivation trap of baked goods every time and then they're suddenly rolling out paczkis and pepperoni rolls, and ugh... the ever-changing ice cream flavors are waiting at the end of the rainbow.The dark chocolate ice cream might be the best thing in the world. Catch it when it's mixed with, say, cookie dough, or raspberry jam... it's a cheat code. Easy win. Milkshakes, drumsticks, ice cream sandwiches, even coffee and other things. There's just not enough time in the year to try it all.