Jimmy John's

4.3 (66)

167 Genesee St, Utica, NY 13501
(315) 624-0110
locations.jimmyjohns.com

Claimed
Sandwich shop
Caterer
Fast food restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Counter-serve chain specializing in sub & club sandwiches, plus signature potato chips.

Service options

  • Outdoor seating

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Brandon Palmer

2024-01

…More

mowlid Nadarevic

2023-06

If I could give -5 I wouldAbsolutely horribleDi not even recieve half the stuff that I wanted on my subMy coworkers same wayI do not recommend this place at allI will never order againAnd we paid $55.00 so here is a pic of where it ended up ,right in the dumpster .

Austin Elliott

2023-08

…More

area fifteen

2023-05

…More

Joal Phillips

2023-05

I would give this third world dictator restaurant owner a zero, but I was concerned the algorithm would have just not recorded it as if I skipped not giving any star. While the food was fine, it wasn't at all what was presented on Uber. Evidently the big crispy roast beef sub sandwich is no longer selling. Not even with American cheese. My Uber points awarded me a free sandwich. But the Utica Boss and owner of this establishment waited til delivery at doorstep to call me telling me he can't delivery a free sandwich to my loved one in his motel room unless I paid for it. Seems to me that's his responsibility to contact Uber, NOT a customer to whom I was told from his employee on the phone that the order is all set and paid for. I don't mind paying for the item I ordered at full price without Uber reward being used, but the lack of communication between owner and Uber is pathetic, let alone the allowing me to believe the order was all set and paid for was just as pathetic. But the owner waiting to drive all the way to doorstep of my loved one to btch about extra money to his face THEN calling me to explain HE would suffer the loss of it was a freebie was unacceptable. That's his problem between the agreement of policies between him and Uber not dragging me an honest customer in the middle! Perhaps the real culprit is Uber and not the restaurant owner, I get it. But how will I ever know unless HE straightens this issue out with Uber. For until he does, it reflects in part on his establishment as much as Uber.

Pushkar Sane

2023-05

The new Chicken Ceasar wrap was great. The beach club was even better. The staff at this place is very polite and told us clearly what the favorite is and guided us with our options. Would come back when I'm in Utica next.

Kelli McArdell

2022-05

I stopped here while in Utica for a quick dinner - customer service was amazing! Eddie, the gentleman working the counter, answered the phones, and was coaching employees all at the same time. He remained calm with what I would call annoying customers. He was fantastic - great customer service skills!

Erma Crouthers

2023-05

The bread is fresher than Subways and they suppose to bake their bread fresh every day. The place is always clean and the people serving you is very respectful. Wish there were other restaurants like this.

Joe Mezzanini

2020-05

really nice Jimmy Johns attractive interior with outside seating. Parking is difficult, but if you are downtown you might be walking anyway. Brand new location - so all modern and super clean. Fast service!

Caitlin Draeger

2019-05

When they say freaky fast they mean it! My order was done within a minute of ordering it. Fresh ingredients, decent prices and no tummyache like my local "Way of the Sub" has been doing me. Cute little shop on the corner, well lit and since it's new, no maintenance or cosmetic issues. Will definitely be back or maybe I'll try the delivery next time! Super happy they put one in Utica now.

ashley

2019-05

Their subs are really good but their prices are really high. My husband and I order 2 lo g subs and it cost is 32 dollars. The place was nice and clean and the man working there was really nice. It took him 15 mins to make 2 subs.

Gina Shoen

2020-05

This Jimmy John's in Utica, NY goes WAY above and beyond for customer service! I was on my way from Albany to Ogdensburg and stopped for a Frenchie. They were in the process of baking the rolls and wouldnt let me leave without making sure I was satisfied! GREAT customer service, great staff!! I will definitely be coming back here when I'm in town for work and will definitely recommend this location to my colleagues when THEY travel here for work as well!!

Annoying Crow

2023-05

BEST PLACE TO GET A SANDWITCH CAW CAWTHERE WAS NO JIMMY INSIDE CAW CAW, KIND OF DISSAPOINTED CAW CAW

Brittnee Mexico

2021-05

Called and ordered delivery to my work and jokingly mentioned that I was pregnant and starving and when I opened the bag he added extra pickles to bag. He truly knows what pregnant women want haha! That was so kind, thank you so much!

Quinton (Qwb3656)

2020-05

The staff are very accommodating and friendly. There was an entire sports team getting food and it took a while to get my sub but they gave me my soda and chips for free!(Also I was not paying attention and did not order the meal, but regardless very nice staff!)

John Dowd

2019-05

I enjoyed the bread/roll. I didn't care for the rest. The other two sandwiches I ordered had errors.I wish they had an option to cook/heat the meat. Cold bacon isn't appealing to me.

Drew M.

2023-05

My family got three sandwiches here and not a single one was correct. Guy behind the counter was super slow, which would have been understandable if he got the sandwiches right.

Bob R

2019-05

The 'Unwich' is delicious!! Healthy, low carb, yet filling. Friendly staff. Dalton was very helpful, polite and knowledgeable. Definitely recommend!

Carolyn DuChene

2023-08

…More

Jameson Shepherd

2023-05

Food is alright. But kinda a rip off. Behold my $9 sandwich. Not worth the price.

gdbuck 280 rem

2022-05

Not bad. One guy was great, he made everything ok after his coworker messed up the order.

D Ricks

2021-05

Great food decent price.thx Rob B you're a valuable asset to the company...

sam mccloud

2020-05

The owner and his employees. Were a pleasure to deal with. I bought 10 loafs of bread. Go check them out.

Lynette Strack

2023-05

Friendly service quiet atmosphere clean environment!

Donna Moore

2021-05

Alot of meat in sub compared to subway the counter person was kind and helpful

dennis leavitt

2020-05

I like there subs been around the city and tryed a lot places but Jimmy John's keeps me coming back!

Ruthie Liggins

2022-05

The food was good and a very friendly and clean place

Edin Selimovic

2021-05

Very friendly staff nice clean interior, good food.

Jen

2021-05

Great food and service, very fast also.

Valerie Hoover

2022-05

Great subs and very friendly service!

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30 AM-6 PM
Tuesday 10:30 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM-6 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM-6 PM
Friday 10:30 AM-6 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM-6 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet