1st Class Aquarium

Sergil Rahmtulla

2023-06

I was really nervous ordering as this was the most expensive coral purchase I've ever made and they were to be shipped all the way from New York to Texas but boy am I glad I did. Truly a first class experience. Delivery process was super fast, answered my many questions quickly and professionally, the price was very good, and most importantly the corals are absolutely ridiculous in real life! :)

louis trento

2024-02

I was at this store looking to buy a saltwater setup. I chose a 90 gal fully equipped and said I would come back with a down payment and the rest when I was to pick up. Soon after I went and found the store closed. I’ve gone several times after that and still closed. I’ve called and was told under renovations and have seen this explanation in reviews. However it’s now more than 2 years and still not open and I went and bought a 125 set up elsewhere. It’s a shame cause it’s close to me but I’ve found other places to spend my money. I don’t understand how you can keep a shop and not allow customers in?! The ordering online thing may be convenient to some but without a replacement guarantee . I won’t try it . I’d rather see the corals and fish in real life than just a picture . I will say the staff was extremely knowledgeable and friendly

Ronnie Barth

2023-06

Heard about this shop from a fellow reefer who has one of the most amazing torch collections I've ever seen. His quote, "They are expensive but the quality is second to none". Took a chance and let me say, the flesh on these torches...wow...flesh for days. Insane color. Fat, healthy and vibrant!!! Unfortunately I had some issues and if you've been reefing long enough you will know what I mean when I say the blame game happens all too often in response to failures. THIS is what sets them apart from the rest. The willingness and responsiveness of the owner blew me away. Anyone can sell you nice corals. Anyone can take responsibility for the sale when things go right. What makes you different is when things don't go right. Trust is a hard thing to have for an out of state purchase of a live animal. I've found that trust and I've found my go to vendor for torches. They will not disappoint in any way. Thank you for being you!!!

Eros

2024-03

I wish they had more freshwater fish, and more decor other then lava rocks, and slate. Other then that nice clean tanks. Tons of salt water fish and I saw some great prices for things other stores would want a arm and a leg for.EDIT: THEY'RE NEVER OPEN AND NEVER PICK UP PHONE.... SINCE COVID THEY CLOSED THE DOOR. LIKE DUDE ITS OVER STOP BEING PARANOID AND OPEN THE DOORS. I USED TO BUY HERE ALL THE TIME

Alex Karampelas

2019-06

Very cool place with alot of cool fish. Good place to go with a kid.

RANDY SCHUSTAL

2019-06

This place cant get any better Ronnie and his staff are amazing . We are new to the world of salt water tanks and they have been nothing less that professional and helpful. Phone calls are answered promptly and they are so accommodating. Their fish are beautiful and healthy. They have guided us from the start, monitored our tank to make sure it was fish ready and provide maintenance service.Truly a great place to deal with.

James Dileo

2020-06

Honestly probably the best live fish store I have ever been in, and is most certainly the best live fish store in Staten Island. Whatever you need they will probably have. Ron is very helpful and goes above and beyond that of what any other retailer ever will. He helped me tremendously and selflessly putting my problems first and his profits second. Truly a great live fish store and the only one I will be going to for anything thus far. Prices are on point for all merchandise but livestock seems to be a little higher than but they are certainly worth their value because you know you can trust them. The only problem for me is it is a thirty minute drive whenever I wanna go there.

Amanda Caputo

2018-06

The fish here are exceptionally healthy and beautiful... healthier than any other fish store I've gone to. The staff is friendly, and they are extremely knowledgeable. I can tell that they genuinely care about their fish! They have a huge selection of fresh & saltwater fish, (they have two big rooms full of fish to pick from, and they have some really exotic ones)! They also sell corals, rocks, driftwood, tanks, tank covers and lights, fish food, decor, gravel, filters, filter media, etc.

Mike “Mossimo” Lopardo

2023-09

Came here twice and could not get in both times … they don’t care about staten islanders salt water needs because they don’t take walk ins or answer the phone when you return to make an appointment

juan marcial

2019-06

Just saw the nastiest female customer ask the owner "whats his horoscope sign?", he refused to tell her and she became irate,frustrated and threw racial remarks. The owner kept his cool. I commend him for his professionalism.

Leslilynn Meadows

2020-06

They have nice salt water displays but the variety of fresh water fish wasn't there. I didn't also feel like it was a fish store... it didn't feel like an inviting fish moment like I used to have when petland was open...also no one greeted me, explained anything, didn't say thanks for shopping at the store... I got 2 fish but I'm going to find another place to buy my fish

Erica Pearson

2019-06

So we are now complete fans of this store. The woman whose name I don't remember is so knowledgeable and helpful. If you are a novice or an expert, you will be happy you went. My boyfriend loves this store!

Sean

2019-06

I was so glad I found this place. It's such a great thing to have a dedicated aquarium store and not have to go to Petco. The tanks are all so we'll kept and they have a great variety of fish. I live on the south shore so getting here a trek but it's worth it. Call ahead and ask if they have something particular in stock.

Robert Paniagua

2022-06

Mix feelings I never know if I'm paying too much or too little I feel there is not consistency on their price, which might be because of demand or supply but still. I always come out of there broke.

MIGS GABRIEL

2021-06

Great fishkeeping shop. They always have nice stock . They maybe pricier than other local shops but it's worth it. They always give good advice too if you need help they know what they're talking about

Wyatt Payne

2023-06

Great place. 1 star off for early closing time. Wish they were open for a few hours longer.Edit July 1 2022: are you guys open for in store shopping yet?

Pete Mackauer

2020-06

The guy was rude and obnoxious, and miserable. He didn't want to do his job and didn't want to give advice. How do you run a aquarium service and don't even have a service to test your tank water. I've spent about $200 every two months for awhile and still had bad experiences with with this guy. I've lost multiple fish worth alot of money a pice.

Steven Roig

2019-06

Quite knowledgeable and thanks of fish seemed to be well cared for. Tanks were clean and well stocked. Not pushy for a sale and they had both fresh as well as salt water fish. They also have bait and tackle equipment for fishermen. A little expensive but healthy fish.

Anthony M

2019-06

Great selection of freshwater fish. Tamara was extremely helpful. She helped me to select the right fish for my new aquarium and setup the tank properly before adding any fish. I will be coming here for all my aquarium needs.

Alyson Mahon

2020-06

Today a young man who identified himself as the owner harassed my 70-year-old father, who was looking to buy an aquarium, in front of my 7-year-old son. He refused to answer the questions posed by my father, a stroke survivor who has difficulty finding the correct words, and ridiculed him with his friend. The man then yelled at him and refused to serve him, even attempting to prevent him from leaving to comfort his crying grandson so that he could call the police on him. He ought to place a sign in the store window stating that he does not accommodate senior citizens or those with disabilities. Shame on him.

Theresa Hunter

2019-06

This place is wonderful.They have just about everything you could need and if not they will order it if its possible.They have good prices and a wide selection of products from salt to fresh water.I would definitley recommend this store.

L. C. Green (IamStonecandle)

2021-06

I have bad luck here. Twice I've bought, twice they've died. The fish look healthy until I'm home. I can only blame myself. Staff are courteous.

PJ B

2018-06

I like this place, they have a good selection of items and decent prices. Saltwater fish and corals look like they are being well cared for. Didn't see any pests on the live rock.

Chris Dhan

2018-06

First off let me say they have infected fish!! 1. They watch and follow you around non-stop like you’re about to steal something. 2. I bought a small goldfish from them a few weeks ago and added the fish to my main tank, the next day I discovered the goldfish had passed away and saw it had ick all over its body. I started to quarantine and treat all my fish as fast as i could however within days all my fish have died! Before i jumped to conclusion that the store gave it to my fish, i went there and looked at their tanks and almost every other tank have a fish that was infected with ick or dead floating. I WOULD NEVER RECOMMEND THIS PLACE TO NO ONE!!!

John Vigorito

2019-06

Awesome place , staff knows what they are talking about, their stock is second to none on the island, and they take care of it, place is very clean, and the staff is very helpful and knowledgeable, i love this store and the fact that is close to my house, once again thank you 1st class, you will definitely be seeing me again and i will also recommend your business regards, John vigorito

Anthony Denicola

2018-06

Gave the place a try bought a sail fin and a diamond goby, the staff woman was getting electrocuted from the diamond gobby system via live wire, still needing the fish I was persuaded into buying the fish ,which died before making it in my tank. The sailfin is ick infested and the lack of lights over their tanks prevented me from seeing this , probaly why he was priced lower than the next tank . Now I have a tank full of sick fish and lost my 2 year old gold rim who was huge !!! Highly unprofessional shouldn’t have such exotic fish in movement if they are unhealthy ........ sadly just another place with poor stock maybe this was a fluke but shouldn’t happen with high end saltwater fish priced that highly .....

Randy P

2022-06

Honestly the best selection of torch corals I have ever seen in my reefing life in any store , the dude got everything nice!

Francisco M

2020-06

This is hands down the best place to buy fish. So many mom and pop petshops are closing. I am proud to support these guys. They are awesome!

Johnnie Katsimanis

2019-06

What an amazing fish store. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. The tanks that they keep the fish in are spotless. Would highly recommend. P.S. They sell both fresh and saltwater fish.

renee cullen

2021-06

Very clean and healthy fishStaff was wonderful and very helpfulI would definitely go back there if I need more fish.