Pennocks Icecream

Angelique Rose

2023-07

I really like the waffle come and the ice cream was perfect. Cash only

Maddie Short

2023-07

I was a regular customer here until I got yelled at for throwing out 1 cup in their trash while waiting in line for icecream the greasy haired lady told me no outside trash and that I needed to take it out, I had no problem doing so until she refused me a napkin to dig through the garbage to retrieve my small Dunkin cup, she then forced my mom to dig into the trash with her bare hands to retrieve the cup. I went to the icecream shop down the road after called creek side custards and told them what happened and asked if it was okay if I threw out my cup and the lady said absolutely and said to throw out whatever I needed. Also icecream prices are much cheaper at the cream side custard! And taste better too.

Roadblock Thompson

2023-05

Great tasting ice cream from a classic roadside stand. Plenty of outdoor seating although the parking lot is oddly shaped, it only adds to the charm. A steady stream of locals were in line before and after my visit. The rainbow sprinkles were a bit too crunchy for my tastes.

David Simmons

2023-06

The best. I would come here as a kid after going to wescotts beach.It the best. And the flavor burst. The are impossible to find. I have looked. And looked.Traveled over 1000miles and this is the best stop!!

Karley Walker

2023-07

I am from Kentucky and I asked for Butter Pecan ice cream and when I said it she rudely corrected me and said i was wrong because I didn’t pronounce it how she did and then proceeded to call me dumb and i’m 14. DO NOT RECOMMEND

Mandee F

2019-05

My husband and I LOVE ice cream and are very picky about finding good places that we like that consistently have great flavors and good quality ice cream. This is one of the few shops that offers the flavor burst options (my husband's favorite) and we visited numerous shop around the county trying to find these! The staff are always friendly and work hard. There are lots of places to go in the area, but Pennocks is our #1 go-to!

Heather D

2019-05

I grew up eating at this ice cream stand. And have always enjoyed it and was satisfied. This time not so much.. I took 2 of my daughters there 4th of July and was VERY disappointed. The quality is fine , Its the quantity that’s to be desired 👎.

brian smith

2022-05

Nice little ice cream stand. They have a good assortment of Hershey's ice cream and around 25 flavors of soft serve. The Pina Colada twist was awesome!

Jodi Daniels

2019-05

A tad bit expensive for the sizes of the ice cream. Ice cream was a little gritty. And 75 cents for sprinkles and flavor burst is a little much. Not a lot of parking. One person working.

Daron W

2020-05

Great location along a busy highway. They serve many flavors of soft serve as well as hard ice cream. The staff is friendly and there is plenty of parking.

Martha Fortune

2021-05

My favorite ice cream in the world! I have been coming to Pennocks every summer since I was a little girl. The staff are friendly and the ice cream is incredible.

Sandy Aubertine

2023-07

The greatest ice cream shop this side of rhe Mississippi.

Moon-Suk Kim

2023-05

Best ice cream ever tasted...really love this place.

Jim Brule

2023-05

Good ice cream, friendly service, cash only, sloooooow service

Molly Smith

2017-05

Great ice cream and service. 10/10 would recommend.

B.D P

2023-06

Very nice little ice cream shop.

Greta Smith

2018-05

Best effing ice cream and service in the whole goddamn world. also great clams

Jeff C

2019-05

Ice cream is good but the staff is extremely slow.

Donald Hanson

2020-05

Great ice cream, huge servings

Alana Vargas

2020-05

Pretty good variety of Ice Cream!

Jon Mosher

2019-05

Great Ice cream at affordable prices

Sarah Stemper

2022-05

Great flavor selection, and good prices

Ron David

2019-05

It's an ice cream shop, what else do you need to know.....

JS W

2022-05

Good portions, good icecream

Frank Rocco

2023-07

No one waited on us

Reta Looker

2022-05

Always enjoy the ICECREAM there

Bill Sanderson

2020-05

Great ice cream!

Diana Sheitz

2018-05

Good ice cream!

David Peters

2022-05

Best in New York

Paul Hoy

2020-05

Great job!