Magros Italia Pizzeria

Ethan

2024-02

Every time I get pizza here I'm pleased. They have a great all around pizza and awesome crust!

Dog Guard Of CNY

2023-10

We found this hidden gem five miles from our camp with fast service on a busy Friday night. We loved the pizza, pizza roles, and wings. The dough had a perfect soft inside with a crunchy outside - the sauce and toppings were a great quality. The wings had a good portion of sauce which we loved because a lot of places don’t put enough sauce on their wings.

Gary FRINK SR

2022-05

Not as good as it once was but it may be that I'm just old and have been getting food there for 20+ years. I do like that they'll sell you dough to make it yourself witch is the best for us.

Sandra Standish

2024-02

…More

Ryan Buchanan

2024-04

…More

Bonnie Bender

2023-05

The best steak sub EVER! Great pizza too and the salads are huge and fresh. If you’ve never been there, you have to try. You will not be disappointed

David Moffitt

2022-05

At least once a week we reach out to Magros to make us dinner. Nobody wants to get home from work at 7pm and have to cook a good meal. They are always ready to fill that gap. I just wish they had everything listed in the online menu. Great food. Decent price. And they employ a lot of local teenagers. Average waiting time is 30 minutes.

Jessica

2023-10

…More

Stephen Yang

2022-05

Great fresh slices with lots to choose from, I had to try the CBR Chicken Bacon Ranch slice. It was so good and the dough is thinner like New York style so you could fold it and go. There are a couple of tables to sit down and eat but of course you can get it to go as well. Stop on by at the main intersection in Cincinnatus and you'll see the signs and smell the great food.

Audra Rowley

2018-05

Asked for a menu and ordered. Lady was very nice and understanding. Good prices and good food

Cynthia Rivera

2021-05

The staff is finally friendly. I usually love everything I get here. Unfortunately, tonight the pizza was mediocre and the wings were awful. I ordered bbq wings and garlic parm wings.... disgusting. The wings were swimming in a ton of grease and sauce and the sauces were awful. Spent almost $40. Don’t think I will eat here again unless they go back to the better sauces they used for the wings without drowning them

Chrislori Furgison

2021-05

Some what friendly kinda like a hole in the wall place pizza was very greasy could have poured 4 cups of greasy off it and it would of still been to greasy.

Travis Boyzuck

2021-05

Really good pizza and wings. Lost my order once. I order from here monthly and they get it right most of the time. Prices are a bit high and they don't have many or any real specials. But the food is really good.

Gary Stevens

2022-05

The young man who waited on us Wednesday morning 8/18 made our day! Haven't encountered such an exceptionally great person in a long time!And the bacon pizza we had was outstanding!

Ivan Delia

2022-05

Great pizza made by real ingredients and fresh toppings. The staff and owners are great people who love what they do. The current person in charge is working hard at improving every aspect of the building. Stop by and see for yourself!

Ryan Williams

2020-05

Good pizza. Not the best pizza I've ever had but for a small shop I would say 7/10. Prices weren't super low but pretty in line with most other places around, maybe a little higher. But it's the only pizza shop in Cincinnatus so you pay for convenience. Wings were in the same line as the pizza. Have eaten here numerous times and will continue to do so without hesitation.

Tim Sweeney

2016-05

Dined here numerous times. Good pizza and full dinners. Prices are inexpensive. It's rustic but clean. There aren't many places to eat around Cincinnatus, so it's great that this place is available. They have enough seating for several larger groups.

Dannette Tomlinson

2022-05

We are fortunate to have Magro’s here in town, but … I am sadly disappointed recently. Last evening my bill was over $50 and my order was so wrong! We ordered a stromboli w/sauce on the side. We got stromboli with ricotta, no mozzarella, and sauce in it. (We don’t like ricotta) The BLT sub had onions. The menu says “optional”. We neither ordered them or like them. The pepperoni pizza was burnt and the cheese ravioli were empty. On a good note, the cheese pizza was very good! Our orders have been wrong previously, but I chalked it up to a bad night. Although I like to support local business, I can’t afford to continue. My advise is, check your order before you leave!

Oguz Yucel

2021-05

Their food are delicious and you know it always fresh because they make after you order it. It's local and I'm glad they are having business here than you can have yummy food. Also I realized most of them Lady which is I'm more proud their business...

Joe Marturano III

2022-05

Years ago never had any problems. Every time you order out it's something else. Tonight ordered a large pie and a calzone. Large pie turned into a cold slice pie and they charged us for it; Wife didn't even notice the extra cost till we got home. That pie was sitting there and no one bought a slice so they threw it in a box and sent it to us. 35 miniutes they told her on the phone. SMH Getting ridiculous

BuenasNoticiasdeIL

2023-07

The best place in Cincy. Nino makes this place like home. Get a pepperoni knot. You will be in love❤️

Jack Stevenson

2023-05

Just love there pizza 🍕 amazing food and staff very friendly and service has been great

Ralph Brown

2023-07

…More

• Woodman (‪PsychoJoe‬)

2023-05

…More

Jolene Rose

2022-05

The best home town pizza Ever !! I can't go home without stopping and getting something either pizza or subs. I love their extra cheese pizza. The staff is always nice and friendly.

Amy Golden

2023-07

Love the availability of foods, quick to grab lunch with many people with everyone getting what they want.Vegetarian options: They have a ton of veggies and will add them to anything as well as many meatless optionsKid-friendliness: They will make anything however you would like it

Robyn

2022-05

Food here is good, the pizza is definitely a good New York style pizza, The service is great here as well, there isn't a great deal of seating or parking. There are customer restrooms though which are clean and we'll supplied usually.

R Pendragon

2021-05

Good food friendly staff.(edit) just did an order got the usual 2 large thin crust pizzas and not did they only up the price some but now they want to put a 4% charge on when you use credit cards no longer be ordering here any more.

Jason Eldred

2021-05

A medium pizza pepperoni onion extra mushroom and extra cheese $27?? GTFOH!!! Oh our prices went up!! Guess so!! Pizza prices more than steak dinner I guess. You are your own fate for sure. Raise prices like that!!!! Seriously?

Edward Gonzalez II

2018-05

It's a small town pizzeria. May not be the best in the world but they're not bad. Actually, they're pretty decent. They get a 4 start rating by default due to all other pizza options being a minimum of 10+ away.