Duff's Dairy Treats

4.6 (199)

2609 State Rte 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
(607) 863-4330

Claimed
Ice cream shop
Miniature golf course

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Adam K Ballard

2018-05

Great food and even better ice cream.

Jamie Swetland

2023-05

Awesome selection of foods, treats and of course ice cream. Friendly staff. I ordered clam strips and fries and they were perfect. Not over cooked and dried out and nut under cooked and chewy.Saturday night karaoke by Gary on the bandstand and open air listening?!! Awesome good time! My wife, kids and I sang along, danced, cheered and even took the stage for a song! Great family fun.

Philip Maynard

2023-09

Not actually closed - new ownership (2023) just doesn’t have access to the Google listing. Great food and ice cream; friendly and helpful staff!

Susan Dunham

2021-05

Great food, ice cream and service. We love to play Mini Golf with the grandchildren. Very reasonable prices and specials for the Mini Golf. We always have a great time and they treat us very well. Personally we prefer to support the small family owned business over corporations.

Victor Domine

2022-05

This place is a nice throwback to 1950's dinners with its music and heritage. It's a draw from around the area. We discovered it while camping. It provides a comprehensive menu of hot dogs, hamburgers, chili, chicken, cheese steaks and other hot food. It offers an extensive list of ice cream, sorbetto, sundaes, shakes and more. They even offer a dog menu with soft serve ice cream and kibble. Behind the small shop are ample sitting areas, covered benches, free corn hole, and music from the 50s. They also offer a small mini-golf course I've never used. This business is seasonal so it may not be opened after Labor Day or before Memorial Day so call ahead to make they are open.

David Moffitt

2022-05

We don't just go to Duff's for deserts. They have a pretty sizeable lunch and dinner menu as well. Plus you can grab a table just about anywhere on the lot. Want to treat that someone special? I recommend taking them to the gazebo. Great food. Great prices. Family friendly atmosphere. And they have miniature golf.

Abbie Converse

2023-08

They have great prices and the food/ice cream is really good. I totally recommend.

Edward Lindaman

2018-05

I look forward to stopping by here whenever i'm in the area. Food is pretty tasty and consistent quality. Love the wide variety of ice cream options at reasonable prices. Service has always been good, but it can get crowded. I especially appreciate the beautifully maintained grounds with gazebos and other structures with plenty of areas to sit, relax and enjoy the snacks.

Jay Davis

2023-10

Great ice cream and regular fried food. Stop here every summer

Terri Wiker

2023-10

Great food, service and of course Ice Cream!!

Cheryl Otero

2021-05

Delicious soft ice cream flavors is my favorite treat but they serve other fast foods as well ! This place is centerly located so it's easy to find. I would like to see more outside seating optiond.

Susan Schake

2023-07

The biggest and best hot fudge sundae I've ever had. The owner is also very nice.

Joe Drugotch

2023-05

18.00 for a hamburger, chili dog and onion rings. Order was wrong, got a Chilli cheese dog. I wouldn't serve that to the wild animals,on top of it it was cold in the middle. Their sauce for the onion rings was watered down horseradish. The hamburger looked like a slider. Couldn't eat it. MCDONALDS has a better quality burger with onions at a 1.79. 😢service was pleasant. First and last time goingWill make the trip to Whitney Point.

Cate T.

2019-05

Great ice cream and you get a lot. I ordered a small and it had three scoops (hard ice cream). I didn't give it 5 stars because they give no indication as to if there is one line that feeds to both windows ( as it should be) or if there are two lines. Most of us were following the feeder line plan and then some people came, went up to the open window and got served before all of us who were waiting. I hope their ice cream fell off their cones!

Mary Chadwick

2020-05

Normally it's 5 star for sure! Wasn't interested in any grilled food. Good thing, cuz they were having issues with the grill. Plus, my husband wanted a soft ice cream and I was planning on a chocolate milkshake! Not today! Neither machine was working! Gotta admit, I felt bad for the girls at the windows. Customers blamed them for broken machinery! Really!!! Geez!!!

Michael Rich

2023-06

We love this place very comfortable atmosphere. Plenty of shady places to sit and enjoy the country scenery.

charlie jamieson

2023-05

Love to stop here for many different kinds of ice cream! (almost) always bump into someone I know. Great location.

jake stanton

2022-05

Nice, local spot for great ice cream and even better food. Owner is super nice as well. Don’t miss out

Karen Stearns

2021-05

Duffs has done a great job with updating a favorite ice cream spot. They have a lot of gazebos and picnic tables to sit at and eat their delicious food or ice cream at once the COVID closure has been lifted. Our dog loves their puppy sundaes! There is even a mini golf course on the premises and porta potties too.

Judy Leonard

2019-05

Great place to go for a bite to eat and some ice cream. Reasonable prices and friendly staff. After you eat and enjoy your ice cream you can play a round of mini golf!

Elaine Foster

2022-05

They have several flavors of the best ice cream around!! Worth it!! Large servings...yummy. food is great too!!

Nadine K

2023-05

Always a great place for ice cream or burger. Patty and crew are top notch with friendly service.

Angel Abrams

2019-05

Super awesome food, I had the chicken sandwich and some green beans! I also tried the root beer floats which were soooooo amazing! And I came all the way from Jersey just for Dave’s!

emma keator

2019-05

Love love Sharon and family so glad we have them in our community. Great people and so giving. Awesome place for food and ice cream and great prices.

richard karwowski

2022-05

A nifty place in the middle of nowhere. Employees were extremely helpful and cooked up a couple of burgers real quick so we could get back on the road how nice.

Lenin Ayala-Bey

2022-05

Owner is rude, not very polite at all. Food is mediocre, for a place to be out in the middle of no where, they should at least be able to have communications skills.

Jeremiah Mcmillen

2023-05

Ice cream is good and reasonably priced. They have a big yard for kids to run around and be kids.

Dustin Sherman

2018-05

Great ice cream, very friendly and fast staff, with an awesome scenery. They held their 2nd annual Daves sunday rundai race. I was extremely impressed!

Chandler Mills

2022-05

Delicious ice cream with so many choices. Love the spot out back to relax and enjoy your treat!

Dirk Alberts

2022-05

Amazing place food is awesome and the ice cream is better

Opening Hours

Monday 11 AM-5 PM
Tuesday 12:30-5 PM
Wednesday 12-5 PM
Thursday Closed
Friday 11 AM-9 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet