4.6 (177)
119 N Main Ave, Aztec, NM 87410
(505) 636-2261
fivefiftypizzeria.com
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
KImboeslice K.O.
2023-10
Overall, I had a great experience here. The pizza was 6.2 rating. I just wish the crust was a bit more crunchy. It felt a little too soft for my liking. The staff was amazing here, and it makes me want to come back and see them. This place is better than other pizza places I've gone to wat at. I really wish they had pizza by the slice. They would have evey9ne coming by for that.
Maria S
2022-05
Fantastic Pizza! We were traveling through town and stopped in with a family of 5. Everyone was satisfied. It’s one size 10” pizza- that’s it.My college kids were full with the pizza and a side salad (which were a good size). Good value all around! We recommend! Yum!
Philinda Herrera
2024-04
…More
Craig Crowder
2023-07
Wow, this was great!I really enjoy a green olive pizza. It's kind of a strange deal for me, but I really like it. This is one of the few places that I can get green olives on my pizza and I enjoyed stopping here on my way through Aztec, heading to colorado.Check out the photos!
Mark Navarro
2024-01
Solid pizza, they're very understanding and accommodating to special requests.Their online ordering would greatly benefit with a "No Cheese" selection, prominently displayed in a separate area.There are people that have an lactose intolerance. Also vegans; that one I don't understand.
Cassandra Crocker
2022-05
My partner and I just moved to town and tried this place out on our date night. It was a bit of wait, but well worth it for FRESH WOOD BRICK OVEN PIZZA!!! absolutely DELICIOUS, we are gonna make this a regular thing for us!! Love the cute sidewalk patio, perfect to grab some beer on tap as well. We LOVED the apple cider!!!
Warman Hall
2022-05
This is a nice local restaurant. They have a small but very good menu. All pizzas are the 10-in size. You can also pick up beers from the on site brewery! I had the green chili cheeseburger pizza and it was amazing!
rnnr nr
2022-05
the workers are really nice and the place is cool, i loved the hanging lights~ the margherita and cheese pizza were the ones we picked and lemme say the tomatoes smelled so good! i didn't try any beers yet, waiting for next time :)
Casey Boyd
2020-05
Pizza was good but wish they had more than one size. We got the jalapeno popper pizza we wanted to try something different than our typical pizza. My fiance LOVED it. The dough was thin but held up well and fresh jalapenos are always better.
Willow Bassett
2023-11
…More
Madi Bates
2023-10
It’s refreshing to find a new place that doesn’t taste like fast food!The pizzas were yummy! The crust was a perfect crisp but not overcooked!Their ranch was also good and the employees were nice.We drove from Farmington and something new and good was definitely worth the drive to us!!
Andrew Foster
2023-10
I adore the wood fired pizza here. They’ve recently changed ownership to a well respected restaurant family in the area and the quality and character they f the place has only gone up. They make personal sized pizzas, one pie will easily feed one grown man. I recommend an extra crispy jalapeño popper pizza. Do not miss this local food if you’re passing through, nor the beer from their microbrewery around the corner.
Desiree Laughery
2023-11
…More
Janie Felix
2023-12
…More
Emily C.
2020-05
Great service and good pizza! If you stop by before 2, take advantage of the lunch specials. Pizzas are personal sized and can be turned into a calzone (same price) if you prefer. Friendly service and quiet atmosphere. They also have about half a dozen brews on tap, but we didn't try any this time.
Cy LuPone
2024-03
…More
Signe Rogers
2023-10
This was my family's favorite place too eat. We came at least once a week if not more. We went back after the new owners took over and they kept the name but changed the recipes?? My kids wouldn't even eat it, it used to be their favorite hands down. We wasted 2.5 pizzas. The pizza sauce was so chunky it wasn't a texture I could even get behind. Very sad turn of events for the regulars!
Lara Exparza
2021-05
I stopped in Aztec while on a road trip. It was a great decision! I ordered a calzone and a cider beer. Very tasty! The staff was super nice.
Gabrielle Griego
2023-05
Best oven baked pizza I've ever tasted 😋 hands down!
Samantha Gomez
2023-05
We love 550! My kids love the pizza and it’s always a good experience, I haven’t had a pizza I did not like and the salad is also fresh. The pizzeria is a go to for our family. We also frequent the brewery, they have a huge yard (you can get the pizza delivered here), they have pool tables and an old pin ball machine. I’m not a beer person but when they have their mixed drinks they are great, they had a cranberry orange margarita that was great!
Pat Lyon
2022-05
Super fine brew and pizza. The pineapple brew was a surprise smooth, rich palate and not overtly sweet or acidic. The pizza toppings are first class and the dough is light, flavorful and crisp.
Cassi Ramon
2024-04
…More
Man Lew
2023-07
Easy one way parking on the south side of the building. The place was empty, save for the two employees in the building. Two pies (margherita and a pepperoni) took about 10 to 15 minutes to make. The pizzas come only in one size (I want to say 10 inches). Kind of expensive ($14 & $12) for the size compared to other pizza places I have been to. The pies were cooked good and the taste was there (5/6 out of 10), but nothing to write home about. I had a beer (in house lager - $5) and it was not as I was expecting. It looked like a watered down blonde as opposed to a large. The taste was that of yeast and dishwater.The place is decently clean and the restrooms are clean as well. Friendly staff and a hometown feel.
Chelsea Williams
2023-12
…More
Shon Mills
2024-03
…More
Kelly George
2024-04
…More
Jo Ann Culpepper
2023-12
…More
Emily Silos
2024-03
…More
Juan Campos
2023-09
…More
Josh Dickens
2023-05
Took my employees here working from out of town for dinner Monday night. AWESOME pizza, and pasta. Been to a lot of brick oven pizza joints but these guys have a great pie!!! Good vibe and they love what they do you can tell. Keep up the good work guys. 👊🏻
| Monday | 11 AM-8 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11 AM-8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM-8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM-8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM-8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM-8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Scan the QR code to leave a review.
Powered by bulkqrcodegenerator.com
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population