Anthony's Homemade Italian Ice

Jeremy Sullivan

2021-05

Great location. Been here numerous times, even though I pass several ice cream parlors on the way. Anythony’s has a huge variety. Friendly staff, and they also have two new vinyl tables for easy clean up which are a big upgrade especially with Covid.They also accept Cash, Credit and Debit. Very helpful. There is a $7 minimum with CC/DC.All around- wonderful place to spend 15 minutes enjoying ice cream and family.

KristaDora Lyman

2023-08

We LOVE Anthony's, we live in town amd can walk there. They are always so nice, know our kids by name and have watched our family grow. Ms. Aaliyah the owner is a true gem. Happy to support a small business and highly reccomemnd stopping by.

Stephanie Martin

2023-05

My husband and I stopped up for the first time since moving into the area. We brought our dog with us. I got mint chocolate chip, my husband got a hot fudge sundae and I asked if they had pup cups & they said yes. Ice cream was good and the pup cup was a cup of vanilla ice cream with a milkbone stuck in it (so cute!). My dog approves as well! The worker was very friendly and I will definitely be back! They have a large menu so there is plenty to try in future visits!

Puglorf

2023-05

I've lived close to the shop for 16 years and I go as many times as I can in a week they're custard and water ice are both very delicious The staff is always nice and make sure sweet treats and a timely and efficient manner I will always keep coming back here as long as I live in this town five stars would highly recommend

La Reyna

2023-05

Nice variety. Had a banana boat. Huge portion. Milkshake was small for the price. Would return. Friendly staff. Parking available and an outdoor sitting area. Open late.

Paul W

2021-05

An amazing selection of frozen treats makes it difficult to make a choice of what to have. I finally decided to go with a sugar cone of their Cookies n Cream ice cream that's made on premises. It had huge chunks of real Oreo cookies in it, smooth and cream texture; it turned out to be an excellent choice! Additionally, the service there is fabulous!

Rachel Pantaleo

2016-05

Holy cow the choices! They have a huge selection of ice and soft serve flavors (30 different soft serve flavors and about 15 ices), plus additional treat options like sundaes and banana splits. They even have malted milkshakes, an old fashioned favorite. Their flavors are delightful without being overwhelming and it's true ice, not frozen slurree like their chain competitors.The only downfall is that service is a little slow but that's because it's a small but popular business, most nights there will be a line, but I feel that it's worth it.Also, can't forget - it's cash only!

Den F

2023-06

Their ice cream and water ice is delicious. They have a lot of options and the people that work the counter are very nice.

dan Spurlock

2023-07

All the ice cream was soft serve. My first cone (a small) fell off the cone. It was replaced for free.

Edward Martz

2018-05

Delicious local ice cream and water ice spot. Vanilla soft serve ice cream on a waffle cone tasted good.This is the creamy light kind of soft serve. I will be back very soon to try the water ice. It was a little bit pricey, almost $5, but I can walk here, it's extremely convenient to forest gate apartments.

Facoffe Gagetit

2023-12

2 thumbs way up.Love this place.Kid-friendliness: It's a water ice factory and ice cream shop.

Christine Corrigan

2018-05

Unfortunately we have had negative experiences two times -last year and then again yesterday. The soft-serve is swirled to appear full, but they leave a gap inside. It tastes okay, but for the price and lack of ice cream, there are other, better offerings locally.

Nancy Fox

2023-05

Great ice cream and water ice. Good prices. Pleasant service.

Sara Makemson

2023-05

The ice cream and water ice is always delicious. And I love the new loyalty rewards program.

Stacey Sharp

2019-05

The staff and owner are spectacular! My kids love their ice cream and water ice. They are friendly and always greet you with a smile!

David Powell

2018-05

Soft serve was deliciously rich, smooth, creamy, and flavorful. The water ice in my mango gelati on the other hand was not very flavorful. Could barely taste it with the vanilla soft serve.

Emily DiMarcantonio

2023-05

So many unique choices and always friendly staff. I look forward to them opening every season :)

Jesse Lombardi

2019-05

This place puts the tony Back In anthony’s. customer services was Great, a young man by the name of Kyle ( I wish I could type a BIGger K) helped us out with our 4 arctic swirls. We were new to this ice cream shop, but Kyle told us the arctic swirls was not only his favorite creamy treat But he also loved making them! Would recommend to anyone lookInG for a sweet breaK!

Cherylann McDermott

2023-06

Always a great experience! My kids love this place!

Mark Johnston

2023-05

Our favorite place for ice cream and water ice. Our pup loves the pup cups!

Caitlyn Snyder

2021-05

Amazing, staff is always so friendly. This is my favorite ice cream place by me!

Ren Pro

2023-05

Staff is so friendly! Best water ice in the area hands down!!

David Becker

2022-05

Great place to get ice cream. Their water ice is underrated, give it a try.

A. O'Brien

2022-05

Expensive for pretty average ice cream. The staff isn't all that friendly either from my experience.

brandon noe

2023-06

Great prices and great ice cream!

MaryAnne Serra

2019-05

Awesome service, delicious treats. Not your franchised water ice. Give it a try🍦🍧

Joe

2021-05

So glad they reopened! Love this place. Excellent soft serve ice cream & water ice!!!!

Deborah Dera

2023-05

Love this place! Close to home and staff is always friendly!

Tiff W

2019-05

It's always good selection of flavors when I go. Never had a problem!

Stacey C

2021-05

Vey clean! Friendly service! Best water ice and shakes around!