Cupsaw Market & Pizzeria

Sarah J. Daudelin

2017-05

We've purchased pizza here on several occasions now and I have yet to be disappointed! Not having grown up around Jersey or New York pizza, I've been impressed with the deliciousness of the pizza here compared to non-chain pizza places in the South East. From all the pizza I've had up here in the North so far, I have to say that Cupsaw Pizza is my favorite! The pizza is always fresh, it's great tasting, they are generous with cheese and toppings, and the sauce isn't overbearing. I'm not a red sauce kind of person, but it's not an issue with this pizza! Yum! I've also had great service every time I come here, food pizza or just picking up a random item that I ran out of.

Grace Mulyk

2023-05

I get lunch from here a lot after school and they give u a lot of food for what your paying. staff is super nice and you definitely get more than you pay for when you order food

Zechariah Johnson

2022-05

Great tasting pizza, I got the carnivore. I got a 20 Oz drink and it was hot, ask for a cold one or cup of ice

Michael Kurtz

2018-05

Friendly staff, nice selection of goods and decent pizza! The seating area is a bit lacking, but the benches outside are good enough on a nice warm day.

Emily O’Herien

2023-08

Great little spot to pick up lunch or snacks. They have a little bit of everything. Their Wednesday Indian night menu is AMAZING and fairly priced.

Carole Cole

2023-05

I have been a fan of this hidden gem for 3 years or more..EVERYTHING is made to perfection. I've had the pizza heros wraps calzones appetizers all of it is delicious.. I use the SLICE APP and it gives points but also allows updates on the delivery time. It arrives at my home warm and delicious within the time sent via text message.

Ashley S

2023-08

I called at 145 to see if the market was open as it is a holiday. I was told yes we are closing at 4:00. I got to the market at 3:00 to find it closed. So irritating. I understand it is a holiday-simply provide correct information.

Lad Bell

2021-05

Fantastic breakfast sandwiches! Fresh and big! Coffee is always hot and fresh. This is a great local deli and market with very friendly service. The owner Sam always keeps it nice. Always worth the trip. Covid protocols are in place for a safe visit.

Tim Dailey

2022-05

Well run with quality goods - Hours are the weak link!Been there a few times (31 years living in Cupsaw)Amazing they close at 8pm even on a Sat night?Best coffee on tap in town. If they matched Lucky 7hours (open till 11pm) would be 5 stars.

Brendan Magone

2023-08

Wonderful local place with lots of basic necessities and tasty sandwiches. Friendly staff, good service. Thank you Cupsaw Market!

Timothy Dailey

2023-05

CHANGE YOUR LISTED HOURS..Hiked over here after Google said :open till 6 PM. Closed at 5:10 - several other came up to the door in consternation while I sat writing this. Otherwise a great place.

Shoryuken

2023-05

Super solid place. Usually grab lunch and dinner. Haven't had a bad experience. Everyone is polite and professional. Always asked about my opinions and how they can improve. They are kind and care about continuing to improve.

Meghan Phillips

2020-05

Everything we order is delicious every time. Taco Tuesday is our most recent favorite. Sam runs a great market and gives back to his community. It’s a win-win!

Frank Ciercielli

2022-05

Excellent Local Full Service Deli with Excellent Breakfast Sandwiches, Coffee, Deli Sandwiches (they do not skimp on Loading them up !) and Pizza of may Types !! The also Deliver !! Try it out, You will not be disappointed. !!

Kevin Dusenberry

2023-05

Happy to have a place like this right in the neighborhood. Great food from their deli/pizzeria and the standard mini-mart product selection is good too.

Charles Mampe

2018-05

Quite a bit better than a couple years ago, basically new owner coming up on 3 years?Decent selection for a local "walk to" place (in Cupsaw Lake), good fresh made food like pizza, calzone and recently "fresh made ethnic food" Monday and Tuesday. Something different for a change.Lots of pricing close to Stop & Shop but no traffic or commute.

Maria Velasquez

2018-05

Great selection of last minute staples and snack foods. Pizza is delicious, best in town! Friendly staff and owner is very involved in the community.

Stephanie Tran-Chong

2021-05

Stopped in here after we went hiking at Ringwood trail. Great surprise: the pizza and calzone are delicious! Very fresh ingredients and great staff!

Karen Dodds

2018-05

Pizza is outstanding! They also have a really good choice of ice cream bars. Better than the usual!

Karen Dodds

2022-05

We got Cheese steak, eggplant calzone, ham & Swiss cheese sub, roast beef & American cheese sub. Everything was outstanding!!

Louis Engelbrecht

2017-05

Childhood favorite. Great place for kids to hangout, grab snacks, meetup, etc. Great pizza (like 8 years ago, not sure how it is now.) Good selection of products.

Maria Wheeler

2020-05

Raw bacon and burnt eggs on our $5.00 sandwiches--took home and re-cooked the bacon but the sandwiches still sucked. :( TWENTY minutes later . . .

Danny Chong

2021-05

Great pizza, and delicious. The dinning area has this great view of the lake

David Daudelin

2017-05

Born and raised in Jersey and this is one of the best pizzas I've ever had.

Anthony Tamuzza

2022-05

Been going here for years and never had a bad meal.

Michaela Schwab

2020-05

Great food, great people, great price - will be going more often

Chris Tashik

2018-05

Excellent pizza and wings. Quick delivery to Cupsaw area!

Peter Cibenko

2019-05

Do not go here. Management is rude & extreme slow service. Staff forgets your order & overall terrible experience.

Amir M

2019-05

I love going with my dad we love this place the staff here are so friendly and sweet Keep up the great work. 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗

krupa patel

2017-05

AWESOME PIZZA THE BEST IN NJ!!