Maddalenas Cheesecake & Catering

Benjamin Silverman

2023-08

Don’t just go for the cheesecake. They have a huge section of frozen dinner entrees too. Bought the wild mushroom raviolis and they were outstanding. Loaded with mushrooms and you could tell they were home made. Will be stopping in anytime I’m passing by!

Katelyn Erchick

2024-01

…More

Vincent Paruta

2024-03

…More

Todd Benson

2024-03

…More

Kate Gold

2023-07

Wow, probably the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. Blew me away! The customer service was amazing, such a welcoming atmosphere and small/family business feel. I’ve had a lot of cheesecake in my life and it truly was incredible and likely the best I’ve had.We also got a loaf of banana bread and it was moist and delicious. But the vanilla cheesecake was the star. 20/10 amazing!

Zen Traveler

2020-05

You can talk about whose Cheesecakes are the best, or you can use that time wisely and eat the best cheesecakes. There’s something for everyone at Maddalena’s, and that’s a very good thing.

Cassie Hahn

2023-10

…More

Lisa R

2023-11

…More

mackramae s.

2019-05

This was one of our favorite touches to our wedding day. They made the most beautiful three tier cheese cake that our guest raved over!!!! One week later I still have friends reaching out to me asking where it came from, and if we have any extra to share. We of course did not share- and ate all the extras post wedding- though one of the groomsmen did sneak off with a lot of it. Though delicious the cake also had so much sentimental value as well- my parents also had their cheese cake at their wedding, and it has been at every big event through out my childhood. We can not thank them enough, and cant wait to have their cakes at our big celebrations down the road.

Ban Ayoub-Azab

2023-05

It was my birthday cheesecake 🙄 i am very surprised about the rate and the comments. Unfortunately, the cheesecake very bland no flavor i was very disappointed in my birthday day . I am with keto 3 years and that was the worst taste ever.

Nicole Eresman

2023-08

We had Maddalena’s dessert truck come for a party we hosted at our home. From the very first conversation, Janet was clear with details, their services, the menu (which is insane and delicious 🤤), and pricing. Scott was with us for the day and was an absolute pleasure to work with. All of our guests raved about their chocolate dipped cheesecake and banana options, the apple pie, and cannoli filled cheesecake… so good! Thank you so much for such a wonderful experience working with you and your team.

Thomas Mauriello

2023-05

I have been driving by this place for over two decades and finally stopped.If you drive between New York/New Jersey to South Jersey or Philly, this is a worth-while spot to pick up a delicious cheesecake to give to whoever you may be visiting.Yes, the cheesecake was delicious! It was quite light and airy but also very creamy with a sweet, unmistakable flavor that will have you going back for another taste till it's gone. I was wondering about the ingredients and if they used a local source for their milk/cream because it really was quite special.The store itself is just a tiny little space with very friendly staff who will kick off friendly conversation.Space consists of two large glass counter cases filled with various selections. They offered samples too. In addition they had iced coffee and apologies I can't remember exactly but some kind of frozen lemon drink that looked really good and I should have tried it.Seemed like some other snack or sweet selections available like cookies etc.I thought the cost for a cheesecake was quite reasonable.We will probably stop again in some months when we hit the road again. Worth a stop.

Amy Rosina

2023-05

Thank you for making my best friend's birthday so special. She loves cannolis and cheesecake and rainbow sprinkles and to have them all in the same dessert was epic.

Ruben Soto

2023-08

I pulled in because of the award winning sign, but they were closed. I called the number and they let me in to buy an Apple Crumb Pie. This pie was the best apple pie I have ever eaten. Will be coming back. Thank you!!

drew flook

2023-06

We make the trip from Easton, because it's sooo worth it. From the hearty and delicious pot pies to the chicken and sausage gumbo, you can't go wrong! And if course the amazing award winning cheesecake! You can truly taste the love and care that goes into each and every product. Can't wait to stock up again soon!

Mitchell Kramer

2023-05

Saw a sign last year that they offered Thanksgiving dinners and heard very good reviews. This year we selected our Thanksgiving turkey and sides from them. From my initial phone inquiry to the Thanksgiving day ( yes pick the time you want ) pick up I had the most friendly professional experience. Every step of the ordering process to drive through pickup was very well executed. My turkey was delicious, moist and warm! It came in a Styrofoam box that kept it the perfect temperature. The sides all tasted home made and extremely good. The apple pie was a home run. They only make a certain number of meals so order early.

Joshua R

2023-07

This cheesecake is so good that it has the potential to end world war 3 when it comes. This cheesecake should be put in a fine art museum and sold for $20,000,000. This cheesecake should win an Oscar for best Actor of 2024. This cheesecake should be carved as one of the found fathers. All in all, meh.

Ralph Lelie

2024-03

…More

Eric G.

2023-05

Having passed by this store many times, I finally stopped in and purchased one of their popular (frozen) apple pies. The pie was very good, but it was also very expensive at $27.50+ in comparison to other very good fruit pies that I've purchased in the Somerset-Hunterdon-Mercer County area for $10-12 less. However, check out their website for a variety of food products, and make your own determination at least once, and more if you like your selections. 2/11/23

Chef Jeffrey TakeAChef

2022-05

Maddalena’s Apple Pie is the best in the industry! Amazingly sweet, tangy and wonderful! I always come here for just this pie!

Max Samad

2021-05

I love this place first time here had the pleasure of meeting the owner she made a few recommendations. I love the vanilla cheesecake i’m definitely going back to try more food

Jeremy Reeves

2023-05

We had our Thanksgiving meal ordered from maddalenas and it was delicious. The turkey was nice and juicy. I'm usually not a fan of stuffing but the cornbread stuffing was really good. Everything was delicious and the best part was we didn't have to cook as we hosted Thanksgiving.

Breanna Harris

2022-05

Love this place. Learned about them through a food truck event and tried the frozen cheesecake on a stick and it was amazing. Visited them a few weeks ago and go fresh cheesecake, frozen cheesecake, and a frozen chicken pot pie--all were delicious. Took a trip back to order Thanksgiving dinner and grab more cheesecakes and they had fresh chicken pot pie today. Great place, great food, and great people that work there.

Kathy Reeves

2022-05

Everything is delicious and homemade. Starting with the savory items and everything in between. Cheesecake there is phenomenal and all items are baked with love and the best attention to detail. This little place off theInterstate on Rt. 31 in Ringoes is a must try. You will be happy you did.

Adam Papp

2023-05

Delicious cheesecake and cannolis on a stick and apple crumple pie. Amazing and large amount of choices on their menu when they are at events with there Cheesecake Truck. Very recommended, best in NJ.

Felicia Episcopo

2021-05

Everything from this place in amazing. The food and the cheesecakes. The cheesecakes just melt right in your mouth, so rich and so creamy. It is literally heaven in your mouth. Secondly, who would’ve thought a chicken pot pie would be good from a cheesecake place. Well guess what it is! Every single time i serve this pot pie everyone cannot stop ranting and raving about it. I just recently tried a pasta dish from them, what do you know top notch. I’d rather spend the money to come here and buy the food than go out to eat.

MARK TURITZ

2021-05

Bought a few mini frozen cheesecakes. They were very good and size just right. Wish there would be a crust on the bottom for a little texture change and taste. Otherwise it defrosted quickly and is a perfect size for one person.I'll be back.

Ryan Brockman

2019-05

Cheesecake has always been my favorite dessert. When I was a child I loved any cheesecake, but over the years I’ve become more particular. These days I’m often only satisfied with cheesecake served at fancy restaurants. That’s why I’m so grateful for Maddalena's. Maddalena’s cheesecake is amazing in every setting and for any occasion. I also love the variety of flavors—for example Key Lime cheesecake is great in the summer while pumpkin cheesecake is my new Holiday season favorite. When you want to make sure everyone is happy, definitely go with Maddalena’s.

Julie Montalvo

2022-05

The apple crumb Pie was simply amazing! We we were only 1 hr into our 3 hour drive, stopped at a red light and saw the sign “Award Winning Apple Crumb”! Thought we’d give it a try & We were not disappointed ! It may have to be a new stop for us each time we take this ride.

Daniel Brun

2020-05

This is our go-to for all things cheesecake! Absolutely the Best Cheese cake as well as a Great selection to choose from! Love that they have gluten free and Keto options to accommodate some of our family members special diets.