Tiffani's Vintage Closet

Jennifer Zuza

2023-07

When I found this little treasure of a store I never went home empty handed always found amazing treasures.Paula has an amazing eye for fashion and she’s an awesome person.Love my amazing movado watch.What a treasure!!!!

Kaitlin Pensabene

2023-05

Went in today with my mother who shops here often and has told me good things. Found many quality, unique pieces that we absolutely loved! Not to mention amazing customer service from the owner, who is very knowledgable and knows her stuff. Overall very honest business and business owner. Will definitely be going back!

Leen Khash

2021-05

What a great experience! Paula is the owner and she was so sweet and gave me a great bargain. I have recommended this place to all of my friends because this place is packed with hidden gems. I got myself a beautiful faux fur coat for under $30! Super cute and unique. I'll be back soon!

Briana Cintron

2021-05

my first time at a shop like this and i had the most amazing experience! the owner is the sweetest person and gave so much insight on all of the items, it was such a pleasure talking to her. i will definitely be coming back for more! my dad and i drove almost an hour to get here and the experience was so worth it. go support this business:))

Samantha King

2022-05

It was my first time visiting this cute gem of a shop and I loved it!! Totally worth the hour drive to not only get a fabulous deal but to also meet the lovely owner of the shop; she is the sweetest. Always gives back and gives good deals! Would definitely go again.

Margaret Heekin

2022-05

Paula is most kind and accommodating. I have shopped in her former store and have found many treasures, This new location is a breath of fresh air.It is a wonderful addition to Front street.Thank You for being my personal "dresser". I couldn't ask for a better storeor owner.

Rodney

2024-01

Awesome place. Owner reminds me of John Gotti's daughter

Megan Huber

2023-05

I absolutely adore this antique shop. I'll go here every day with my friends on our days off. Their fashion is stylish and there's so many good brands. I even found a Y2K purse that will look so cute for photo shoots. Love love love Tiffs! Thank you 💞🍀

Jaime Wolfson

2022-05

What a wonderful experience!! Owner is amazing we just love her. The store is so organized it’s very easy to shop. I highly recommend checking out this gem in Keyport.

Anna Tseytlina

2022-05

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!! The owner is the sweetest person ever! It’s very rare you get to converse and get to know owners, so it was a sweet pleasure to talk to her. The clothes/accessories/bags are SO CUTE!!! And vintage of course!! I am so happy to have stumbled upon this place because I literally cannot find clothes like that anywhere else. I am coming back over and over and over again. MUST VISIT!!

Gianna Caralyus

2022-05

store owner is an absolute queen, best service i have ever experienced!!!!!! probably the nicest couture vintage i have ever seen… 10/10 recommend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Nicolette Del Pino

2021-05

My sister & I came here today to check it out & let me just tell you from the second you walk in to the second you check out the customer service is amazing. Paula is such a kind outgoing person you can ask her anything! Masks were worn, the amount of people inside were being accounted for, and everything was pretty organized. Definitely a place to check out we will be back!!!! Thank you Paula!!❤️❤️

Daniel “Danny Del” Delpriora

2022-05

I mention this store to family & friends in Aberdeen & other places in NJ. EVERYONE always calls me & says there's a great selection & the lady ( Paula) is so wonderful, polite & helpful!!! LOVE it when I refer someone to a store & they have a fantastic experience!!

Tina B

2022-05

I called ahead for hours since it’s a half hour drive. Spoke w/ owner who said, “I would normally be closed, but I’m having a bin Sale today so I’ll be here til 5:00.” So I drive the 35 minutes - get there at 420 and it’s CLOSED. SERIOUSLY?! it’s a small operation - there cant be that many calls - she couldn’t just call me so i didn’t waste my time? Guess customer satisfaction not as important as her plans. smh

Alina Fensterer

2021-05

I really could’ve enjoyed this place more if COVID regulations were being followed. While the owner was very nice she not once had her mask on. I mean it was on, but quite literally on her chin the entire time I was in the store. Plus it was overcrowded so there were definitely more than COVID capacity. I would go back if there was not a pandemic. Cute stuff but not safe for the pandemic.

Michele Torre

2021-05

The owner and her staff were wonderful. I came in with my teens and the owner accommodated them immediately. She has a great selection of items. I will definitely go back and I highly recommend it!

Courtney Thorne

2018-05

My daughter and I Loved it. Cozy store with a little bit of every thing and both ladies were very warm and welcoming😊 My 7 yr old diva left tickled pink with her new dress and wallet. Tiffani's has two new customers.

Hoenn417 Exhale

2021-05

THE OWNER IS SUPER NICE!!! Honest to god. I’m a 23 y/o young man from North Jersey. Came down after I saw the shop on tiktok and was IMPRESSED. I’m more of an accessory type of guy and they have it all. Sunglasses, jewelry (stainless steel, sterling silver, gold), scarfs, watches, etc. OWNER IS SUPER HONEST & GENEROUS WITH PRICING. Highly recommend for designer bag collectors and sellers. Lots of good fur coats. Would recommend visiting often as they have a lot of rotating inventory so you won’t see EVERYTHING that they have in that GOLD MINE when visiting that day. Many blessings to this business and future shoppers.

Remix x

2021-05

Super amazing place!!! I bought these vintage Dior sunglasses that were from her original stash. This seller loves vintage clothing and you could tell. Will definitely be coming again

Kathryn Hammel

2022-05

What a wonderful spot to shop right in the heart of Keyport! Gorgeous vintage pieces at fabulous prices. The owner is very pleasant, down-to-earth, and generous! Will 100% be returning, and highly recommend!!!

Angela Gonzales

2022-05

They just opened a store in Matawan. Amazing customer service, run by a very nice woman who is soon going to open up a bigger room in the store especially catering for teens looking for thrifted clothes (by September 20th I believe!) Got a cute leather skirt that, instead of $79.99, was sold for $25 with a free necklace. Check it out with your friends!

debby rubira

2022-05

The owner of this store was very rude extremely unprofessional she was screaming on top of lungsShe is unfit to run a store yet alone speaking to her employees or customers. She did not honor what was posted or she said she picked and chooses to whom she gives any deals . Extremely extremely unappetizing experience. Be warned

Iyunnah Fils

2022-05

This place is a hidden gem! Owner was super friendly and extremely helpful. Customer service was over the top, great deals and steals for vintage thrift. I recommend Tiffany’s 100%

Anne Kathryn

2022-05

this is my new favorite vintage/thrift store!!! the sweetest most welcoming owners and the cutest clothes that have trendy and one of a kind pieces! if you're into reasonably priced trendy and vintage clothes, this has to be the place !! <3

Clumsy

2021-05

An amazing store with so many things to choose from, the owner offers amazing deals, and she is a wonderful woman, possibly the sweetest woman ive ever met. Surely will be bringing business!!

Hamza Mohamed

2018-05

Paula was super helpful and so nice! They have a great selection and excellent customer service. Thank you so much!! I am definitely going to shop here again soon!

Alisha Naseef

2022-05

Paula is seriously the sweetest and so knowledgeable. She makes sure you know exactly what you’re buying! Also always so many good finds.

Jessica Bilotti

2021-05

Such a great store with so much to offer, and the owner is amazing. So helpful, kind and knows so much. Found so many great pieces for such great deals! I highly recommend!

SoonForward

2020-05

I would not recommend this shop. The owner is very dishonest. I had one bad experience talked to the owner on the phone, thought she was nice because she apologized and pretended she wanted to rectify the situation. Only to be ripped off once again. Will not be returning.

Amaya Marshall

2022-05

Best vintage clothing store I’ve ever been too, the lady at the front desk was wonderful, helpful, and the sweetest lady I’ve meet; and I would 100% recommend for all vintage collector’s.