Giuseppe's Pizza Restaurant

Jeff Black

2024-04

VERY EXPENSIVE!!!!I have never written a review at a restaurant, but had to share my experience here at this pizza place. Ordered a medium pizza three toppings and bread sticks (4 breadsticks) total price $42.66. Thought wow this must be a great pizza? NOT! No wonder they don’t post prices anywhere, not even at counter in store. Pizza was a box full of cheese and mush. Try to eat it, could not. feel so ripped off. Had same experience four years ago same restaurant. If they were to post their prices people would at least know. I hope Caseville visitors don’t think all businesses here are like this one. Caseville has great food and good clean restaurants. Just not this one!

Mary Higgins

2023-09

…More

Sarah Resterhouse

2023-12

…More

Brian Michael

2024-04

Outrageous and runny/ watered down sauce leaving your pizza dough soaked. Disgusting

Angela Main

2023-08

…More

Bobby Melnik

2023-09

Very expensive: Ordered two pizzas for $60 total.Poor quality foods: the antipasto salad had slices of Kraft cheese singles. The pizza toppings were sparse.Poor service: did not have plastic utensils even though it is carry out only.I would not recommend this place!

Kelly Davis

2023-08

2 med 3 topping pizza's and 4 breadsticks $73.00 the pizza has always been fantastic but not for this price. And she was rude when I questioned the amount. Until new mgmt, I will never go back

PWilly

2023-08

…More

J. min

2023-05

Ordered a pizza by phone. Was told it would take 45 minutes. Showed up 45 minutes later to pick up order. Rude lady rung me up and took my money. Then I waited another 45 minutes. Still no pizza. Finally after getting slightly impatient about 15 minutes later the pizza comes out. Now if this was a good pizza one could say it was worth the wait and rude service. However, this was the greasiest most disgusting thing I had ever seen. Not to mention it was rather expensive. Oh well we had fun feeding their garbage to the seagulls. Now we know.

Timothy Tower II

2023-11

…More

Scott Matuszak

2023-05

Listen to other reviews! EXTREMELY OVERPRICED!!!! Ordered 2 large pizzas, 1 with Pepperoni and Bacon, 1 Aloha BBQ Chicken Pizza, and 2 orders of Honey BBQ Wings! $80!!!!!The "wings" we're small little Chicken Tenders (more like nuggets) and a side of Honey BBQ sauce for dipping, not tossed as the description and picture showed!The BBQ Chicken Pizza had regular pizza sauce on the bottom and a light drizzle of BBQ sauce on top unlike most BBQ pizzas were the pizza sauce is replaced with BBQ sauce.The pepperoni and bacon pizza was mega greasy and was barley cut at all. Had to use our finger to split each slice apart and pulled half the toppings off during the process!$80 for this trash! Prices are not listed on the menu. 100% let down and complete waste of money. Have to take out a mortgage just to afford 1 meal.

Jerome Fisher

2022-05

Ordered large all meaty. Never paid $27 for a pizza before but I figured I’d give it a shot. Glad I did. It was really big and good. Most likely was the best pizza I ever had. If I’m in the area again this will be a go to place.

Christopher agnello

2023-05

Medium pizza and a large antipasto salad $37. The pizza was ok. But the salad was a complete joke they used sliced American cheese and honestly almost no toppings in general. I mean with this quality it might be time to change the name to Joe's Pizza just so people know what to expect

Angie Hoskey

2023-08

…More

Navy River Rat

2021-05

I live here in Caseville. Grew up eating MANY of Joe's pizzas. they were the best! Haven't had one in years. Got one last week and it was the worst I ever had. No tomato sauce, and the cheapest cheese I ever tried to chew! The crust however was the best in town. But in this town that ain't sayin much. I wish one place in town had good pizza. At least it was baked correctly all others in town are usually RAW! If one place in town could make a consistent quality product with in house delivery they would RULE this town year around ! Until then I will not spend $21 on something I can't eat.

Ryan

2021-05

Did not actually buy the pizza, here’s the breakdown:Requested to buy 1 medium one topping, 1 large three topping, and 1 side of ranch for pickup. When asking for the total (since the circus of a business does not list prices on their website), the lady replied $50 (don’t remember exact total). After our shock trauma, I asked to hold to see if that was okay with our group.. It was not. I kindly requested to cancel, and that’s the moment the clown lady on the phone hung up. Do not recommend.

mike richards

2023-05

I’ve had their pizza before and knew it’s ‘ok’ not great but wasn’t being too fussy. But the prices are now just ridiculous. One Large pizza and large salad was $45. When people complain of inflation here is a perfect ‘greed’ example. It’s just a local business screwing people.Never again will I order from this place.

kieley phillips

2022-05

I ordered a small Greek salad extra feta and extra pepperoncinis did not get extra of either, yet I was charged $20 for a SMALL salad. That’s honestly ridiculous and was completely not worth it. The pizza was okay but definitely won’t order from here again.

Mike Jerisk

2023-05

Came up from the Flint area to camp at sleeper. Ordered 2 large pizzas. 1 with pepperoni and sausage, the other ham and bacon. We also ordered bread sticks.$62 dollars later for 4 premade breadsticks and pizza was not cut and toppings were light.No prices on their menu and that's how they get you to order. No one should spend 62 dollars on 2 pizzas and 4 bread sticks.Watch Out!!

Matthew Cunningham

2019-05

I brought a group of 11 in late on a Thursday evening. Place wasn't too busy. Maybe two other tables. Very simple decor and atmosphere. This place looks like it hasn't changed since it was built. However, very clean and welcoming. They got us sat immediately. Very simple menu.... I like. Pizza and a handful of Italian dishes. Have a few items and do them well. Pizza was good not great. The crust is on point. Sauce is nothing special. Toppings were fresh and flavorful. Service was good. Poor lady was only one there and handled our table like a pro. We will more than likely return.... Good place for a simple pie

Christi Poirier

2018-05

The pizza was great, perfect crust, great toppings and sauce....the rest was horrid. We figured $6 breadsticks would be good... they were not. We were served 4 cardboard logs drenched in butter and powdered cheese... We wanted water to drink, but they told us no. They offered us bottled drinks from their cooler, and they were not cold. Luckily, the pizza was amazing. Extremely overpriced...but the pizza was worth it. I would get pizza as take out, but I would never eat there again.

SpiffyPeanut

2020-05

Waitress acted offended that we wanted to dine in, and she kept texting while talking to us and getting our menus. Food took forever and pizza was not good. Our pizza’s bottom was very hard we had to cut it with a knife but the rest was doughy. The prices are very high for the product you get. A medium low quality pizza, 1pop, a cup of cold soup, and some mushrooms was $40. The waitress ran my husbands card and stood over him watching him until he put a tip down that she did not deserve. Do not recommend

Jameson Higgins

2018-05

I'm going to shoot straight: you will not enjoy your dining experience. The place is always understaffed. The wait times get longer every summer. The decor is lacking. The prices are high. How can I give it 4 stars knowing all of this?This is, beyond a shadow of a doubt, the greatest pizza I have ever eaten in my life. The dough is cooked deliciously golden brown with fluffy and crispy edges. Mounds of mozzarella cheese and toppings. A flavorful, but not overpowering, sauce ties the whole thing together. Incidentally, they have really good gluten free crust, if that is a consideration for you.Don't get pasta here. Don't get a salad or breadsticks. Get a pizza. You may be frustrated with your wait. You won't like your bill. But you will never forget your pizza.

Joei Zaragoza

2020-05

Very good pizza and atmosphere, friendly. Will be coming back. The only problem we had was that they add 20% gratuity automatically now we wouldn't be complaining but our waitress never came to our table only to take a order then to give us a bill. I told her in order to receive a large tip you need to check on your table, refill drinks, extra napkins, desserts, etc..

Andra Cooley

2020-05

I REALLY wish I would have read the reviews on this place before we wasted our time and money there. When we arrived there were 3 other tables seated. 2 of them were already eating and a family of 5 waiting for their food. It took 10 minutes for anyone to acknowledge us, the server had ZERO personality. After our order was placed we waited another 10 minutes to get our drinks. Little did we know that this would be our shortest wait time. My husband ordered an appetizer of calamari and I ordered breadsticks to go with my lasagna. It took a half hour to receive our breadsticks and calamari. The marinara sauce with the breadsticks was disgusting. It was basically watered down tomato sauce with no flavor. I grew up with a Sicilian grandfather who made dishes like his mother did from the old country. So I know I can be picky but this was ridiculous. And it continued to get worse. My son had ordered a personal pizza and we thought we finally saw it come up in the window but we were mistaken it went to the employees and an employee's little girl who was about 4 playing in the restaurant and kicking a ball while customers were eating. That was special. When our dinners finally came out my lasagna while very hot was gross, boiled noodles with that awful tomato sauce and flavorless hamburger. There was no seasoning what so ever. The only thing positive was they put a lot of mozzarella cheese on it. My husband ordered a sub and he said it was good, but that was all his meal had. No pickle or chips or fries included. My son's pizza was actually decent. Good crust. When we got the bill imagine our surprise when it came to $63! It is $3.00 for a glass of pop! $3.00 FREAKING DOLLARS!!!! The food is disgusting, the service is slow, the decor had a lot to be desired and waaaaay overpriced for what you get. We will NEVER come back here again and will let our friends and family know not to waste their time and money as well.And one last side note. The family that was sitting next to us? Their daughter got sick and vomited in the restaurant, it happens and we sympathized. What makes this noteworthy is that the employees made the parents clean it up before they came out to sanitize the spot and vaccum the area. What restaurant does that???

J

2020-05

Left one poor eatery and on to the next. The young ladies were very rude not saying “hi” or “thank you,” if they are the ones who are dealing with the customers they should at least be taught basic manners/people skills. purchased a medium over priced pizza that ran $18.23. got it home and after looking at it we didn’t even take a bite out of it had multiple pools of grease on top. Not happy with these two places in Caseville-won’t be returning.

Laura

2020-05

5 Stars for life! I look forward to my visits home to enjoy this delectable treat!!! Best pizza hands down. You don't know what your missing if you haven't had a cheesy slice of Joe's pizza! They use top notch ingredients and the sauce is boss. Thank you for your years of wonderful service. Can't wait to grab a Joe's XL special next time I'm home :0) Mmmmmmm!

Phil Poirier

2018-05

While the pizza was actually very good it was pricey. The bread sticks @ $1.50 each ($6 for 4) where a complete let down and I'm fairly certain they were frozen at one point. Also I'm not sure if it was an issue they were having or just standard practice but they couldn't give us a glass of water and told us if we wanted something to drink it had to be something from their cooler.

Franklin Johnson

2021-05

It’s too bad google doesn’t offer 0 stars. This place is a joke. $45 for a large pizza and salad that was disgraceful to pizza and salad everywhere. The antipasto salad was a bed of lettuce with a single slice of cheddar cheese and maybe 5 or 6 pepperoni. The pizza was greasy and floppy and we gave up on our first slice. Total waste. They clearly prey on folks visiting for the weekend. Eat anywhere else in Caseville if you value decent food.

H. Olsen

2022-05

Good pizza that has green olives as an option. They serve canned mushrooms on the pizza that gives it a good chew along with the chewy crust. The minus is you can't eat inside and they are only open during dinner hours, no lunch hours.