Edgartown Meat & Fish Market

Lis Bluford

2024-04

Always delighted by the well curated selection here. Top tier meat, great seafood options - this is such a reliable staple to the community. I love that they support local bakers, they have starbucks drinks, their produce is always fresh...I am always looking for a reason to pop in for one thing and leave with 10 extra goodies!

Marnely Murray

2019-05

This is your one stop shop on island! As someone that lives in Edgartown year round, I appreciate having a market like them open through the winter. Reasons why I love it: they have well stocked shelves of essentials but also fun pantry items - if you want to make any kind of ethnic food, they have sauces and spices to go with your meal. Their meat and seafood cases are always packed with deliciousness. Try their steak tips on the grill, you will fall in love! They also sell side dishes that are great for when you need to put together a quick dinner. Need ice cream? They've got it. Fresh mushrooms and vegetables? They have them! Freshly made sushi rolls? YES! Frozen fried onion rings? Yup, they have them! Plus wine and beer, a Starbucks outpost for everyone the needs their SB hit from time to time, plus they carry so many local products like MV Sea Salt and Val Cakes desserts and Not Your Sugar Mamas coffee. Overall, just an awesome market and the owners are local to the island and the nicest people ever, the staff is so friendly and always helpful!

jack phelan

2024-01

Thanks for having fresh sushi available the day before new years! We bought three rolls, two nigiri and a sashimi and had a delicious dinner! The Nigiri is big with a lot of rice - very filling.

Brian Tran

2023-05

Very fresh fish, even lobsters are alive. Big variety of tasty to cook marinated meats and seafood (crab and salmon cakes). Wide selection of high quality canned food, spices, beer and wine too. And a coffee bar.

kathy chou

2020-05

I'm here to speak of its bagels...some of the best homemade fresh bagels ever! I love the everything bagel -- 5 days later, it is a little dry but soft - toast it up and its like fresh again. They don't go rock stale like commercial junk. I don't get gaseous from these gluten bagels prob bcs they ferment them properly instead of using crazy preservatives to speed things up. Great paired with some local cheese and honey

Victoria Naifeh

2021-05

I thought this place was small and pricey. It is, but if you are buying meat, you need to head to their butcher counter. My family bought marinated chicken, steak tips, and swordfish and loved every bit of it. Easily my favorite meal on the island was cooking this stuff at home. I recommend!

Lars “Elias” Elias

2021-05

Only place on island where you can get Starbucks Coffee. They do not have all their offerings but they have the most popular drinks and coffee blends, along with the seasonal specials like pumpkin latte, peppermint etc. Besides Starbucks breakfast sandwiches, a mean Bagel with Lox, they have, in my opinion, the best Togo sushi on the island - it is Grab and Go. So you can't order off a menu as far as I know, but they use all real fish, it's as Authentic as you can get for American Sushi, top it off with a price , when compared to others, looks like a bargain. Then of course there is the rest of the store!

Ryan Connery

2021-05

My entire family and I went to Martha’s Vineyard and had a great time. We got coffee at this shop everyday and half the nights we picked up dinner here. They have a great selection of already marinated meats that you can just put in the oven or on the grill. What a perfect concept for a vacation area. Give it a try.

Ashley Hallgren

2022-05

Love this local market. Fantastic bagels and amazing seafood and butcher counter. The marinated meats are delicious and impressive. Perfect for vacation needs when you need to feed a crowd quickly or just for everyday meals and need a helping hand.

Julia Tarka

2022-05

Don't miss the the House Steak Tips they are phenomenal, staff is incredibly helpful if you have questions just ask. They have everything you could need for a cookout for an entire week on the Vineyard.PRO TIP: they make a sandwich with said steak tips if cooking in general is a step to far for you

Lauren E. Galinsky

2022-05

Great selection - a bit of everything. House steak tips keep us coming back and the seafood, bakery & beer/wine are also good. Expect to pay A LOT for convenience & quality (and avoiding stop&shop lines!)

Liz Ronty

2016-05

The meat market has some phenomenal selections. The team can answer any questions you have, order special meat/fish and have it in a day or so, and give you recipe help. Plus the quality of everything is out of this world! I highly recommend the marinated steak tips and lamb burgers...

Pandemic Reviews

2021-05

Like all Edgartown businesses, masks are required for entry (thumbs up). Sign posted asking people to limit their group to no more than 2 people. I don't know if they are tracking #'s inside but when I went it wasn't too crowded which felt good safety-wise. They had some markings on the floor for distancing at register and at the fresh seafood counter. Thumbs up!

Cay P

2021-05

Edgartown Meat & Fish is a wonderful addition to our community! The service is always fantastic and they have a tasteful selection of grocery items, as well as coffee and food to-go. Highly recommend!

Dino Ferrini (DisDrDino)

2023-05

The Avocado on my sandwich for 1.50 extra was rotten. I tried a piece of it to see if it was okay anyway and it was not. Everything else was fine but huge disappointment with the rotten avocado.

Diane Carr

2022-05

The food, the staff, and the service is exceptional! It is my “go-to” for the best quality provisions on the island…not to mention they serve Starbucks coffee as well!

Christopher Marciano

2020-05

My mother felt very disrespected by the Starbucks staff(01/11/20). They got there before 5 pm and asked for a frappuccino, and the women refused to make it because she "claimed" that the machine was "just cleaned". The door says that the store closes at 6pm on saturdays so i couldn't find a reason for her tone. If there is a rule about a time limit on when we can ask for a certain drink it should be specified somewhere. Very disappointed.

Mary McDaniel

2018-05

Sad sad sausage egg and cheese. There is no griddle here so the eggs are like weird little premadediscs that are microwaved. Yuck. The sausage was the consistency of meatloaf. Not a good breakfast sandwich. Stick with toasted bagel.

Rani

2023-05

Great assortment of food. You can get seasoned meats to throw on the grill and fresh seafood. There's something for everyone.

Steven Ogden

2021-05

Really good cuts of meat and great service. Nice fresh veggies, Lobster tails and Alaskan king crab legs ,etc. Everything you need to make a delicous dinner!!

Dr. Dina BenDavid

2022-05

Consistently amazing service and products… what’s not to love?! Great Starbucks coffee, groceries AND the best fish and meat on the island - all in one place?!?

Wilde Whitcomb

2020-05

Worst breakfast sandwich on the Island. Un-toasted chibatta, hot house cardboard tomatoes, no lettuce, industrial cheese product, dry meat and microwaved egg for 9$$

J J

2019-05

They sold me choice meat and charged for prime. My friend explained the chew and lack of marbling. Coleslaw is 11.00 a pound. Need I say more.

tommy h

2022-05

excellent meat and fish as the name would imply also have a small produce section great for salads smaller portions excellent for 2

Junior Griffiths

2016-05

Delicious pastries and awesome custom coffee, sandwiches and FRESH bagels baked in house daily, did i mention quality fish and meat, gluten free, fresh.

eric carlsen

2018-05

$6.00 for Kevita, I don't think so. Tourist prices.

Nathan Lopez-Mata

2017-05

Great place! I go there to get starbucks alot, they also make sandwiches that are amazing, i would recomend going there if you have never been

Sarah Caledonia

2019-05

Great meat and fish but it is hit or miss when it comes to available cold or nitro brews. Sushi is made on premises but the price point is just to high.

John Hess

2022-05

“The cats ass”! They work hard year round. Always accountable and personable. If you don’t like, go some where else.

Richard Hamilton

2016-05

Sushi chef on the premises. A selection of beers and wine, great meats, fish and prepared foods, sandwiches made to order.