4.9 (34)
2020 S Memorial Dr Ste I, New Castle, IN 47362
(765) 524-4891
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
charlie ropke
2024-05
…More
Adam Warwas
2024-04
…More
cindy smith
2024-02
…More
John Murphy
2024-03
…More
Dawn
2023-07
I'm not one to eat too much sweets, however, this place is awesome! It's absolutely my favorite place to get ice cream or fudge. My favorite item on the menu is the Brownie Sundae (so far 😉), you can customize it however you want! I got 1 scoop of vanilla and 1 scoop chocolate ice cream with caramel syrup on top. Soo delicious! The fudge is delicious and not too rich either. They always have different flavors of ice cream, too. Birthday cake is really good. Highly recommend this place if you want something sweet!
Heather Terry
2023-07
OMG the best ice cream I've ever had... u even get a glass jar with ur milkshake.... u should really try this place out....
Pam Chaney
2023-08
2 scoops of raspberry rumble; dulce de luche sundae, raspberry sorbet. Delicious as usual. ♥︎ We love this place!!
Willie Mohler
2024-03
…More
Jade Yaudas
2024-03
…More
Megan Thurman Ewing
2024-03
…More
Citizens State Bank Indiana
2023-08
We were able to serve Whitetail Sweet Shop ice cream at a recent event, and it was amazing! The owners went out of their way to work with us, and we've had nothing but great feedback on their treats! A great addition to our community.
Logan Thomas
2023-07
Ice cream is good ,but we were disappointed. In our order we requested 2 brownie sundaes. The menu stated it was ice cream, brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream, and cherry. When they came to the table it was only ice cream and a brownie. We then told we needed to ask for the rest to be included. We found it odd that we ordered from the menu but had to specify we wanted items already listed & still paid the listed price.
Jasniequia Rendell
2023-08
A friend of mine told me about this place so definitely had to stop by on our way back to our hometown. Friendly staff and good atmosphere!
Ebony Turner
2023-10
The ice cream was outstanding! The service was so amazing and it being our first time coming to this establishment, you can definitely bet it won't be our last! Just amazing ice cream! Thanks to all of the amazing service from the ladies!
Tina Hibst
2023-07
So today was our first visit of many. Today we did simple I had 2 scoops one vanilla and one cookies and cream and my better half got strawberry road which is strawberry rocky road(in my best GOONIES impression). But while we were there we seen others order ice cream nachos, brownie shake and strawberry cheese cake shake and it had a slice cheese cake on it...I cannot wait to go back and try other items!
Damian Walcott
2023-08
Just had it for the first time today and I loved it! staff is very friendly and considerate, plus everything is cheap and tastes great. the cookie monster ice cream is amazing
Lisa James
2024-04
…More
Mag Na
2023-07
The specialty milkshakes are served beautifully! Great menu, tasty ice cream, fudge and creative drinks. Friendly staff. Really enjoyed my visit.
Christy Ragle
2023-08
When I want a treat, this is where you'll find me! The ice cream is tasty, service is great, and I also love their diet cokes with cherry flavoring (and the GOOD ICE!).
Kristie Poindexter
2023-09
Such a friendly place to visit ☺️ with delicious treats!
Elizabeth Lynch
2023-09
They had pup.cups and our dog lived it. Their ice cream is good and just a fun place to go.
kasey ferguson
2024-03
Best ice cream and great people!
Jill Lang
2023-09
The folks running this place. I love theice cream I've tried.Thank, we need this in town.
Larry Hughes
2024-04
…More
Donna Richardson
2023-09
Really great ice cream so yummy and worth your money
Dustin Jay Cowan
2024-02
…More
Paige Pierce
2023-07
Lots of options for drinks and good ice cream!
Elizabeth Eley
2023-08
The best ice cream in town!
CJ McDivitt
2023-08
That ice cream is To DIE FOR!
Andres Chigo
2023-07
Excellent-Excellent
| Monday | Closed |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 2-9 PM |
| Thursday | 2-9 PM |
| Friday | 2-9 PM |
| Saturday | 2-9 PM |
| Sunday | 2-9 PM |
Scan the QR code to leave a review.
Powered by bulkqrcodegenerator.com
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population