Casey's

DAVID HERRON

2024-04

…More

Sherie Loverkamp

2019-05

Casey's gas station is a neat and clean store. I love their pizza as well, but the last probably 15 times (I am not over exaggerating either) we ordered pizza there they messed it up. We liked it so much I continued to order there hoping they would get it right. Once when I slowly and detailing each thing, explained my order so as to not confuse anyone the young man on the phone was extremely rude and said "not everyone could afford a college education like you". Well guess what I never graduated college myself and that was the last time we ordered from Casey's in Metropolis.

Donna Price

2021-05

Ordered online for curbside and had to wait and extra 45 minutes in the parking lot for my two pizzas. Even went in to make sure they had the order. I pty it in a bag to keep it warm and hot home in 5 minutes. Pizza was cold and the taco pizza looked nothing like they advertise. No chips and only a few pieces of lettuce and cold. Very disappointing. The supreme didn't have all the toppings but it was warm and was alright. Won't order there again.

Coco Divine

2022-05

It has the potential to be amazing. However, they have to figure out how to make quality food when they are pressed for time. I'd rather them give me good food than rush to get it out. Our order was all mixed up because the place was busy. The guy making food was not wearing a mask when Illinois has a mask mandate. Much of our food was overcooked or burned on the outside but not done on the inside. Only go when they have time to make you quality food.

Doug d

2019-05

Food is amazing. I'm a truck driver stuck at the rest area down the road two competitors won't deliver here and I can't grill here the employees at Casey's pizza are life savers delivering when no one else would. Thank you to the employees at Casey's keep up the great customer service

Zac Pensol

2015-05

I got pizza here while attending the Superman Celebration and I really have to commend them for a job well-done! I think there were about 5 of us who split the pizza and everyone loved it! I imagine this place will become a staple for my pizza dining henceforth when I'm in town to attend the Celebration.

AvilaMomnaChristina

2023-07

…More

D. J. J.

2021-05

Casey's Metropolis, IL.At the gas pumps, PLEASE keep paper (with dark ink) stocked for receipts. I travel for work and it costs me time & gives great frustration because inevitably, whichever pump I choose from to purchase fuel, I get the message across the pump screen to come inside for my receipt. The convenience of being able to pay at the pump is lost on that.

bdriving1

2022-05

Casey's always has my heart (or at least my belly, for those scrumptious peanut-butter bites)! And their cleanliness in da kitchen!

Chris Crouse

2023-05

Super rude, wouldn't let me fill up truck, told me me to go down the road, because I didn't know how much it would cost beforehand. Even offered to leave card and license inside. Not worth your time or money.

Matthew Boyett

2021-05

There was a line of people to the counter, guy named Rob was getting everyone out in a timely manner and nice to everyone even a few that need a lesson or two in manners from what I seen good food an good people

Autumn Funkhouser

2019-05

The pizza is really good and the workers are friendly. The store really needs an update and good cleaning. It is an old Casey's.

Connie Heflin

2020-05

The staff is always friendly, they greet you when you walk in the door. Service is great and the pizza is awesome!

Stacey Poole

2021-05

Been a customer at Casey's for a very long time and my children and I love the pizza there

Tina Dorau

2019-05

Our Pizza tonight was disappointing. Casey's usually prepares a delicious pizza but not tonight. The staff were not friendly

Brian Proctor

2021-05

Casey's is a great little store with friendly staff. Their pizza is really good too.

matthew lindemann

2021-05

I love Casey's made to order food. friendly staff. Clean restrooms at time of visit.

Kricket J

2023-05

Check the dates on all your snacks, everything's always expired....

Justin Gentry

2021-05

I love their sausage pizza. I also like their good variety of snacks.

Juanita Ohsner

2022-05

My tire was low, their air is free. Awesome, thank you

Wendy Paladino

2021-05

Everyone is friendly, plus their sandwiches are not hard as a rock, as some right down the road lol

Nickie Leonard

2021-05

I like this location, overall, but I do wish they would get the new sub station added like most of the other locations have, now.

Tom Gibson

2023-10

…More

Doug McLelland

2021-05

Great selection of drinks and great pizza!

Teresa Edwards

2021-05

They have good food and everything you need

James Littlemyer

2017-05

Fast service that offers excellent pizza and Fresh Doughnuts.

Shawn Wilkins

2019-05

Best damn pizza in Metropolis, IL for sure!

John Scheuler

2019-05

Good place to drop in grab what you need get back on rd

Mary Jane

2021-05

Some yummy pizza, every time!

Grant McIntosh

2019-05

Gas station and convenient store with good pizza.